11/17/2026

Bay Area United Against War Newsletter, November 17, 2026

                                          



                                         *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*

 *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*



Support Palestine Solidarity Activists Against Grand Jury Phishing Attempt

By Popular Resistance

On October 16th, former Palestine Action US activists Sophie Ross and Bridget Shergalis were served subpoenas to be witnesses for a federal grand jury in New Hampshire. These came three days after the FBI surrounded Bridget’s house in an attempt to question her, which she did not agree to. Sophie and Bridget have publicly stated that they refuse to testify in this grand jury, and will respond “in solidarity with each other and whoever they have been ordered to provide testimony on”. Those who resist grand juries often face imprisonment and long-term state harassment; yet it is the duty of every political activist to refuse to hand over information to the state.

 

We are aware that this grand jury has been convened in regards to the November 2023 protest against an Elbit Systems  weapons factory in Merrimack, New Hampshire. Sophie and Bridget, alongside two other activists, received misdemeanor charges and a 60-day jail sentence for their participation in this action. More details on the target of the grand jury have not yet been given. The grand jury investigatory process is profoundly secretive, and frequently used to criminalize, intimidate, and network-map political movements.

 

We condemn these subpoenas, and all information-gathering tactics by the state. We agree to defend the targeted activists against imprisonment and other forms of state repression. Preventing genocide is a moral duty and a reasonable action to take. We must reject any attempt by the state to vitiate our movement.

 

Sign on using this f​orm to show your support.

 

We ask that individuals, organizations, and other political bodies sign onto this statement as a show of support, and to circulate it to other organizations who support protests against the genocide of the Palestinian people.

We ask that you encourage your organization to write a statement of support of Sophie and Bridget, and email it to stopfbi@gmail.com.

Signers

Organizations:

Al-Ahrar Palestinian Prisoner Support Toronto, Anti-Imperialist Solidarity, Black Alliance for Peace (BAP), CODEPINK, Committee to Stop FBI Repression, Community Liberation Programs, Community Movement Builders, Demilitarize Western Massachusetts, Diaspora Pa’lante, Freedom Road Socialist Organization (FRSO), International Association of Democratic Lawyers (IADL), Jericho Movement, Labor 4 Palestine, Masar Badil – Palestinian Alternative Revolutionary Path Movement, National Lawyers Guild (NLG), Palestinian Assembly for Liberation, Popular Resistance, River Valley Anti-War Committee, Samidoun Palestinian Prisoner Solidarity Network, Secours Rouge Toulouse, Southern New Hampshire Democratic Socialists of America, Tariq El-Tahrir Youth and Student Network, Third World Solidarity Front, Women United Against Genocide, Socialist Viewpoint

 

Individuals:

Ambrose C, Aslynn Romano, Bradly Conway, Calla Walsh – Independent Journalist, Dani Silva- SNH DSA, Eileen Weitzman- Movement lawyer, Jakhi Isaiah, Jon Blanchette- SNH DSA, Julie Glass, Lydia Alexander, Tania Cregger, Bonnie Weinstein

 *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*

 *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*

 *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*



See the full list of signers and add your name at letcubalive.info


The Trump administration is escalating its attack on Cuba, cutting off the island’s access to oil in a deliberate attempt to induce famine and mass suffering. This is collective punishment, plain and simple.

 

In response, we’re releasing a public Call to Conscience, already signed by influential public figures, elected officials, artists, and organizations—including 22 members of the New York City Council, Kal Penn, Mark Ruffalo, Susan Sarandon, Alice Walker, 50501, Movement for Black Lives, The People’s Forum, IFCO Pastors for Peace, ANSWER Coalition, and many others—demanding an end to this brutal policy.

 

The letter is open for everyone to sign. Add your name today. Cutting off energy to an island nation is not policy—it is a tactic of starvation.

*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*

VIDEO:

What Cubans Really Think About Trump

By Jeff Seal, May 28, 2026

Mr. Seal is a comedian and a visual journalist.

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/28/opinion/cuba-government-us-trump.html


 *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*

 *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*



End Texas Torture of Revolutionary Elder Xinachtli 

Organization Support Letter

Letter to demand the immediate medical treatment and release of Chicano political prisoner Xinachtli (Alvaro Hernandez #00255735)

To the Texas Department of Criminal Justice,

We, the undersigned organizations, write to urge immediate action to protect the life, health, and human rights of Xinachtli (legal name Alvaro Hernandez). Xinachtli is 73-year-old Chicano community organizer from Texas who has spent 23 years in solitary confinement and 30 years incarcerated as part of a 50-year sentence. His health is now in a critical and life-threatening state and requires prompt and comprehensive medical intervention.

Since his conviction in 1997, Xinachtli has spent decades in conditions that have caused significant physical and psychological harm. As an elder in worsening health, these conditions have effectively become a de facto death sentence.

Xinachtli’s current medical condition is severe. His physical, mental, and overall well-being have declined rapidly in recent weeks. He now requires both a wheelchair and a walker, has experienced multiple falls, and is suffering from rapid weight loss. He is currently housed in the McConnell Unit infirmary, where he is receiving only palliative measures and is being denied a medical diagnosis, access to his medical records, and adequate diagnostic testing or treatment.

A virtual clinical visit with licensed medical doctor Dr. Dona Kim Murphey underscores the severity of his condition. In her report of the visit, she wrote: "Given the history of recent neck/back trauma and recurrent urinary tract infections with numbness, weakness, and bowel and bladder incontinence, I am concerned about nerve root or spinal cord injury and/or abscesses that can lead to permanent sensorimotor dysfunction."

Despite his age and visible disabilities, he remains in solitary confinement under the Security Threat Group designation as a 73-year-old. During his time in the infirmary, prison staff threw away all of his belongings and “lost” his commissary card, leaving him completely without basic necessities. He is experiencing hunger, and the lack of consistent nutrition is worsening his medical condition. McConnell Unit staff have also consistently given him incorrect forms, including forms for medical records and medical visitation, creating further barriers to care and communication.

A family visit on November 29 confirmed the seriousness of his condition. Xinachtli, who was once able to walk on his own, can no longer stand without assistance. He struggled to breathe, has lost more than 30 pounds, relied heavily on his wheelchair, and was in severe pain throughout the visit.

In light of these conditions, we, the undersigned organizations, demand that TDCJ take immediate action to save Xinachtli’s life and comply with its legal and ethical obligations.

We urge the immediate implementation of the following actions:

Immediate re-instatement of his access to commissary to buy hygiene, food, and other critical items. Immediate transfer to the TDCJ hospital in Galveston for a full medical evaluation and treatment, including complete access to his medical records and full transparency regarding all procedures. Transfer to a geriatric and medical unit that is fully accessible under the Americans with Disabilities Act. Xinachtli requests placement at the Richard P LeBlanc Unit in Beaumont, Texas. Approval of Medical Recommended Intensive Supervision, the release program for individuals with serious medical conditions and disabilities, in recognition of the severity and progression of his current health issues. Failure to act will result in the continued and foreseeable deterioration of Xinachtli’s health, amounting to state-sanctioned death. We urge TDCJ to take swift and decisive action to meet these requests and to fulfill its responsibility to safeguard his life and well-being.

We stand united in calling for immediate and decisive action. Xinachtli’s life depends on it.

Signed, Xinachtli Freedom Campaign and supporting organizations


Endorsing Organizations: 

Al-Awda Houston; All African People’s Revolutionary Party; Anakbayan Houston; Anti-Imperialist Solidarity; Artists for Black Lives' Equality; Black Alliance for Peace - Solidarity Network; Columbia University Students for a Democratic Society; Community Liberation Programs; Community Powered ATX; Contra Gentrificación; Diaspora Pa’lante Collective; Down South; DSA Emerge; Entre nos kc; Fighting Racism Workshops; Frontera Water Protectors; GC Harm Reductionists; JERICHO MOVEMENT; Jericho Movement Providence; Montrose Anarchist Collective; NYC Jericho Movement; OC Focus; Palestine Solidarity TX; Partisan Defense Committee; Partido Nacional de la Raza Unida; PDX Anti-Repression; Red Star Texas; Root Cause; San Francisco Solidarity Collective; Shine White Support Team; Sunrise Columbia; UC San Diego Faculty for Justice in Palestine; Viva Palestina, EPTX; Water Justice and Technology Studio; Workshops4Gaza.


Sign the endorsement letter for your organization here:

https://cryptpad.fr/form/#/2/form/view/MiR1f+iLiRBJC7gSTyfhyxJoLIDhThxRafPatxdbMWI/


IMPORTANT LINKS TO MATERIALS FOR XINACHTLI FREEDOM CAMPAIGN:

PHONE BLAST: Your community can sign up for a 15-minute-long call shift here: bit.ly/xphoneblast

FUNDRAISER: Here is the link to Jericho's fundraiser for Xinachtli: http://givebutter.com/jerichomovement

CASE HISTORY: Learn more about Xinachtli and his case through our website: https://freealvaro.net

CONTACT INFO:

Follow us on Instagram: @freexinachtlinow

Email us:

 xinachtlifreedomcampaign@protonmail.com

COALITION FOLDER:

https://drive.proton.me/urls/SP3KTC1RK4#KARGiPQVYIvR

In the folder you will find: Two pictures of Xinachtli from 2024; The latest updated graphics for the phone blast; The original TRO emergency motion filing; Maria Salazar's declaration; Dr. Murphy's report from her Dec. 9 medical visit; Letter from Amnesty International declaring Xinachtli's situation a human rights violation; Free Xinachtli zine (which gives background on him and his case); and The most recent press release detailing who Xinachtli is as well as his medical situation.


Write to:

Alvaro Hernandez CID #00255735

TDCJ-W.G. McConnell Unit

PO Box 660400

Dallas, TX 75266-0400

      *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*

                                      *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*




‘Freedom Zone’ launches important human rights event

October 30 Global Festival in Support of Russian Political Prisoners 

_________________________________________________________
.
THE DATE: October 30, the Day of Remembrance for Victims of Political Repression

THE LOCATIONS: Berlin, Munich, Warsaw, New York, Minnesota, Budva, Melbourne, Helsinki, Haifa, Amsterdam, Stockholm, Vilnius, São Paulo, Florianópolis, Batumi, Tbilisi, Belgrade, Riga, Paris, Yerevan, Milan, Vienna, London, Madrid

THE AUDIENCE: Anyone concerned about political prisoners in Russia
________________________________________________________


On October 30, the ‘Freedom Zone’ charity project will hold the largest event in its history. 

Lectures, auctions, letter evenings, film screenings and other events will take place in more than 20 countries, including the US, Brazil and Australia, demonstrating worldwide solidarity with the prisoners of the Russian regime.

Speakers in different cities will include such well-known opponents of the Putin regime as Daria Serenko, Mikhail Lobanov, Sasha and Nadezhda Skochilenko, Ivan Philippov, Alexey Ponomaryov and other prominent Russian exiles. 

Funds raised will go towards supporting political prisoners, covering the costs of legal representation, visits from loved ones and other needs. It is also possible to join the international campaign by making an online donation. 

This global festival will be a tangible expression of opposition to lawlessness in Russia and support for its victims.

Let’s show that we stand shoulder to shoulder with those who have been unjustly convicted!

______________________________________________

‘Freedom Zone’ was founded by Kseniia Kagarlitskaia, daughter of political prisoner Boris Kagarlitsky. Since 2024, the organisation has been holding charity events (festivals) abroad to raise funds for political prisoners in Russia, raising awareness of the unlawful persecution and inhumane prison conditions faced by people in the Russian Federation, as well as campaigning for the release of political prisoners.


Website: https://freedom-zone.com/festival

Contact: Kseniia Kagarlitskaiazona.svobody@gmail.com

+38268347993

Telegram @pruesha

___________________________________________________________________

Donation link: https://buymeacoffee.com/zonasvobodk


Russia Confirms Jailing of Antiwar Leader Boris Kagarlitsky 

By Monica Hill

In a secret trial on June 5, 2024, the Russian Supreme Court’s Military Chamber confirmed a sentence of five years in a penal colony for left-wing sociologist and online journalist Boris Kagarlitsky. His crime? “Justifying terrorism” — a sham charge used to silence opponents of Putin’s war on Ukraine. The court disregarded a plea for freedom sent by thirty-seven international luminaries.

Kagarlitsky, a leading Marxist thinker in Russia’s post-Soviet period, recently addressed socialists who won’t criticize Putin: 

“To my Western colleagues, who…call for an understanding of Putin and his regime, I would like to ask a very simple question. [Would] you want to live in a country where there is no free press or independent courts? In a country where the police have the right to break into your house without a warrant? …In a country which…broadcasts appeals on TV to destroy Paris, London, Warsaw, with a nuclear strike?”

Thousands of antiwar critics have been forced to flee Russia or are behind bars, swept up in Putin’s vicious crackdown on dissidents. Opposition to the war is consistently highest among the poorest workers. Recently, RusNews journalists Roman Ivanov and Maria Ponomarenko were sentenced to seven, and six years respectively, for reporting the military’s brutal assault on Ukraine.

A massive global solidarity campaign that garnered support from thousands was launched at Kagarlitsky’s arrest. Now, it has been revived. This internationalism will bolster the repressed Russian left and Ukrainian resistance to Putin’s imperialism.

To sign the online petition at freeboris.info

—Freedom Socialist Party, August 2024

https://socialism.com/fs-article/russia-jails-prominent-antiwar-leader-boris-kagarlitsky/#:~:text=In%20a%20secret%20trial%20on,of%20Putin's%20war%20on%20Ukraine. 


Petition in Support of Boris Kagarlitsky

We, the undersigned, were deeply shocked to learn that on February 13 the leading Russian socialist intellectual and antiwar activist Dr. Boris Kagarlitsky (65) was sentenced to five years in prison.

Dr. Kagarlitsky was arrested on the absurd charge of 'justifying terrorism' in July last year. After a global campaign reflecting his worldwide reputation as a writer and critic of capitalism and imperialism, his trial ended on December 12 with a guilty verdict and a fine of 609,000 roubles.

The prosecution then appealed against the fine as 'unjust due to its excessive leniency' and claimed falsely that Dr. Kagarlitsky was unable to pay the fine and had failed to cooperate with the court. In fact, he had paid the fine in full and provided the court with everything it requested.

On February 13 a military court of appeal sent him to prison for five years and banned him from running a website for two years after his release.

The reversal of the original court decision is a deliberate insult to the many thousands of activists, academics, and artists around the world who respect Dr. Kagarlitsky and took part in the global campaign for his release. The section of Russian law used against Dr. Kagarlitsky effectively prohibits free expression. The decision to replace the fine with imprisonment was made under a completely trumped-up pretext. Undoubtedly, the court's action represents an attempt to silence criticism in the Russian Federation of the government's war in Ukraine, which is turning the country into a prison.

The sham trial of Dr. Kagarlitsky is the latest in a wave of brutal repression against the left-wing movements in Russia. Organizations that have consistently criticized imperialism, Western and otherwise, are now under direct attack, many of them banned. Dozens of activists are already serving long terms simply because they disagree with the policies of the Russian government and have the courage to speak up. Many of them are tortured and subjected to life-threatening conditions in Russian penal colonies, deprived of basic medical care. Left-wing politicians are forced to flee Russia, facing criminal charges. International trade unions such as IndustriALL and the International Transport Federation are banned and any contact with them will result in long prison sentences.

There is a clear reason for this crackdown on the Russian left. The heavy toll of the war gives rise to growing discontent among the mass of working people. The poor pay for this massacre with their lives and wellbeing, and opposition to war is consistently highest among the poorest. The left has the message and resolve to expose the connection between imperialist war and human suffering.

Dr. Kagarlitsky has responded to the court's outrageous decision with calm and dignity: “We just need to live a little longer and survive this dark period for our country,” he said. Russia is nearing a period of radical change and upheaval, and freedom for Dr. Kagarlitsky and other activists is a condition for these changes to take a progressive course.

We demand that Boris Kagarlitsky and all other antiwar prisoners be released immediately and unconditionally.

We also call on the auth


                                      *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


Self-portrait by Kevin Cooper


Funds for Kevin Cooper

 

Kevin was transferred out of San Quentin and is now at a healthcare facility in Stockton. He has received some long overdue healthcare. The art program is very different from the one at San Quentin but we are hopeful that Kevin can get back to painting soon.

 

https://www.gofundme.com/f/funds-for-kevin-cooper?lid=lwlp5hn0n00i&utm_medium=email&utm_source=product&utm_campaign=t_email-campaign-update&

 

For 41 years, an innocent man has been on death row in California. 

 

Kevin Cooper was wrongfully convicted of the brutal 1983 murders of the Ryen family and houseguest. The case has a long history of police and prosecutorial misconduct, evidence tampering, and numerous constitutional violations including many incidences of the prosecution withholding evidence of innocence from the defense. You can learn more here . 

 

In December 2018 Gov. Brown ordered limited DNA testing and in February 2019, Gov. Newsom ordered additional DNA testing. Meanwhile, Kevin remains on Death Row at San Quentin Prison. 

 

The funds raised will be used to help Kevin purchase art supplies for his paintings . Additionally, being in prison is expensive, and this money would help Kevin pay for stamps, books, paper, toiletries, supplies, supplementary food, printing materials to educate the public about his case and/or video calls.

 

Please help ease the daily struggle of an innocent man on death row!



An immediate act of solidarity we can all do right now is to write to Kevin and assure him of our continuing support in his fight for justice. Here’s his address:


Kevin Cooper #C65304
Cell 107, Unit E1C
California Health Care Facility, Stockton (CHCF)
P.O. Box 213040
Stockton, CA 95213

 

www.freekevincooper.org

 

Call California Governor Newsom:

1-(916) 445-2841

Press 1 for English or 2 for Spanish, 

press 6 to speak with a representative and

wait for someone to answer 

(Monday-Friday, 9:00 A.M. to 5:00 P.M. PST—12:00 P.M. to 8:00 P.M. EST)

       *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*

                                      *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


Dr. Alter speaking at a rally in support of his reinstatement as Professor at Texas State University and in defense of free speech.

Dr. Alter Still Needs Our Help!

Please sign the petition today!

https://www.change.org/p/texas-state-university-give-tom-alter-his-job-back



What you can do to support:


—Donate to help Tom Alter and his family with living and legal expenses: https://gofund.me/27c72f26d


—Sign and share this petition demanding Tom Alter be given his job back: https://www.change.org/p/texas-state-university-give-tom-alter-his-job-back


—Write to and call the President and Provost at Texas State University demanding that Tom Alter  be given his job back:


President Kelly Damphousse: president@txstate.edu

President’s Office Phone: 512-245-2121

Provost Pranesh Aswath: xrk25@txstate.edu

Provost Office Phone: 512-245-2205


For more information about the reason for the firing of Dr. Tom Alter, read:


"Fired for Advocating Socialism: Professor Tom Alter Speaks Out"

Ashley Smith Interviews Dr. Tom Alter


—CounterPunch, September 24, 2025

https://www.counterpunch.org/2025/09/24/fired-for-advocating-socialism-professor-tom-alter-speaks-out/

  


                                      *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


                  *..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*




Mumia Abu-Jamal is Innocent!

FREE HIM NOW!

Write to Mumia at:

Smart Communications/PADOC

Mumia Abu-Jamal #AM-8335

SCI Mahanoy

P.O. Box 33028

St. Petersburg, FL 33733


Join the Fight for Mumia's Life


Since September, Mumia Abu-Jamal's health has been declining at a concerning rate. He has lost weight, is anemic, has high blood pressure and an extreme flair up of his psoriasis, and his hair has fallen out. In April 2021 Mumia underwent open heart surgery. Since then, he has been denied cardiac rehabilitation care including a healthy diet and exercise.





He still needs more complicated treatment from a retinal specialist for his right eye if his eyesight is to be saved: 


Donate to Mumia Abu-Jamal's Emergency Legal and Medical 


Defense Fund


Mumia has instructed PrisonRadio to set up this fund. Gifts donated here are designated for the Mumia Abu-Jamal Medical and Legal Defense Fund. If you are writing a check or making a donation in another way, note this in the memo line.


Send to:

 Mumia Medical and Legal Fund c/o Prison Radio

P.O. Box 411074, San Francisco, CA 94103


Prison Radio is a project of the Redwood Justice Fund (RJF), which is a California 501c3 (Tax ID no. 680334309) not-for-profit foundation dedicated to the defense of the environment and of civil and human rights secured by law.  Prison Radio/Redwood Justice Fund PO Box 411074, San Francisco, CA 94141


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


Resources for Resisting Federal Repression

https://www.nlg.org/federalrepressionresources/

 

Since June of 2020, activists have been subjected to an increasingly aggressive crackdown on protests by federal law enforcement. The federal response to the movement for Black Lives has included federal criminal charges for activists, door knocks by federal law enforcement agents, and increased use of federal troops to violently police protests. 

 

The NLG National Office is releasing this resource page for activists who are resisting federal repression. It includes a link to our emergency hotline numbers, as well as our library of Know-Your-Rights materials, our recent federal repression webinar, and a list of some of our recommended resources for activists. We will continue to update this page. 

 

Please visit the NLG Mass Defense Program page for general protest-related legal support hotlines run by NLG chapters.

 

Emergency Hotlines

If you are contacted by federal law enforcement, you should exercise all of your rights. It is always advisable to speak to an attorney before responding to federal authorities. 

 

State and Local Hotlines

If you have been contacted by the FBI or other federal law enforcement, in one of the following areas, you may be able to get help or information from one of these local NLG hotlines for: 

 

Portland, Oregon: (833) 680-1312

San Francisco, California: (415) 285-1041 or fbi_hotline@nlgsf.org

Seattle, Washington: (206) 658-7963

National Hotline

If you are located in an area with no hotline, you can call the following number:

 

National NLG Federal Defense Hotline: (212) 679-2811


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


Articles


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


1) Israel Kidnapped Iranian Generals in Flawed Hunt for a Missing Airman

Israeli officials were convinced that Tehran was to blame for the airman’s disappearance. Alternative theories got little attention, until now.

By Adam Goldman, Ronen Bergman, Farnaz Fassihi and Hwaida Saad, Nov. 15, 2026

Ronen Bergman, Farnaz Fassihi, Adam Goldman and Hwaida Saad have spent years investigating the disappearance of the Israeli airman Ron Arad.

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/15/world/europe/ron-arad-missing-israel-iran-asgari-hunt.html

People stand in darkness holding lit torches and signs with portraits.

At a protest in 2025 in Tel Aviv, supporters of Israeli hostages held captive by Hamas held pictures of the hostages and of Ron Arad, who has been missing since 1986. Itai Ron/Reuters


Gen. Abdullah Saberi, an Iranian commander, stepped out for a jog early one morning in an upscale diplomatic quarter of Syria’s capital. Israeli intelligence officers waited nearby. Posing as movers, they had slipped past the neighborhood’s security checkpoints.

 

As he headed for a nearby park, General Saberi passed two men who carried an oversize refrigerator box. In a flash, the men restrained the general, drugged him, threw the box over his head, shoved him into a white van and left as if nothing had happened.

 

He was whisked to Israel for interrogation, according to numerous officials in the Middle East, including senior Iranian officials close to General Saberi and a Syrian official who reviewed video of the September 2021 kidnapping.

 

As a veteran of Iran’s powerful Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps, General Saberi knew many secrets. But his interrogators were interested in only one.

 

What did he know about Ron Arad?

 

Mr. Arad, an Israeli airman, vanished decades ago, and the Israeli military says he is the only service member classified as missing in action. The government’s long search for him has captivated the public and has come to symbolize Israel’s commitment, rooted in Jewish tradition, to bringing its soldiers home, dead or alive. Articles, books and documentaries have been produced about the hunt for Mr. Arad.

 

The Israeli government was so determined to find him that, even four decades after his disappearance, it took the risk of kidnapping General Saberi in the shadow of his own embassy.

 

Mr. Arad was the only thing that interrogators asked him about, Iranian officials said.

 

General Saberi’s abduction and interrogation, details of which have not previously been reported, were particularly remarkable because several Israeli intelligence reports had concluded, over many years, that Iran had not been involved in Mr. Arad’s disappearance.

 

Yet time and again, a New York Times investigation found, Israeli intelligence officials gave greater credence to reports and assumptions that Iran must be to blame for the airman’s disappearance or knew about his whereabouts. That belief, which officials said was genuinely held, justified cross-border raids, kidnappings, harsh interrogations and more.

 

The Times investigation also discovered something else: the answer to one of the region’s enduring spy mysteries, the two-decade-old disappearance of an Iranian general, Alireza Asgari. In hunting for Mr. Arad, Israeli officials kidnapped the general, interrogated him about Mr. Arad and then killed him. He had no intelligence on Mr. Arad.

 

“It was a collective blind spot,” said Avi Kalo, a retired senior Israeli military officer who wrote a detailed report in 2016 that, like others, found no conclusive evidence of Iranian involvement. Yet operations against Iran continued.

 

“Iran,” Mr. Kalo said, “was the boogeyman.”

 

Today in Israel, after years of bloody operations targeting Iran, the prevailing thinking among people involved with the hunt for Mr. Arad is that he was never held by Iran, and that Tehran was not involved in his disappearance, officials familiar with the intelligence told The Times. Recent information collected during Israel’s wars with Iran and Hezbollah has only hardened that conclusion.

 

Officials who were once certain that Iran was responsible told The Times that they had most likely been wrong all along, including Raz Zimmt, a former Israeli military intelligence analyst who helped write a key 2005 report that pointed blame at Tehran. That assessment, he said in a recent interview, was probably mistaken because of “a natural inclination to pin everything on the regime in Tehran.”

 

In interviews, nobody suggested that Israeli intelligence officials had intentionally misled the government over the decades about Iran’s role. Rather, they said that the conclusions were based on fragmented or circumstantial evidence and were probably influenced by confirmation bias — the tendency to give more weight to conclusions that fit with previously held beliefs.

 

Such biases have clouded Israel’s vision before. Before the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas-led attacks on Israel, officials were preoccupied by Iran and Hezbollah and underestimated the closer threat posed by Hamas, even as it raised millions and prepared for an assault. Israeli officials were so convinced that Hamas could not muster a coordinated attack that they doubted it despite obtaining the battle plans.

 

Israeli officials were again overconfident in their intelligence before the current war with Iran, when they incorrectly predicted a popular uprising that could topple the government in Tehran.

 

Israel’s foreign intelligence service, the Mossad, declined to comment on the intelligence that it had produced on Mr. Arad and the operations that it carried out to find him. A spokeswoman for the Israeli military said that Mr. Arad was regarded as alive and missing in action.

 

The Times interviewed dozens of Iranian, Israeli and American officials and others directly involved in the hunt for Mr. Arad. The Times also interviewed families, friends and associates of the two abducted Iranian generals. Some spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss military and intelligence secrets.

 

These interviews reveal new details about key moments, faulty assumptions and fatal costs. The hunt for Mr. Arad is, in its own way, a story of generations of mutual mistrust and violence between Israel, Iran and its proxies. The fighting and secret diplomacy have spanned nearly the entire history of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Israeli leaders, no matter their political parties, have relied on intelligence to hold Iran responsible for Mr. Arad’s disappearance.

 

In one indication of how the thinking has changed, Israeli commandos set out this year in the hopes of finding Mr. Arad’s body — not in Iran, but in a small Lebanese village.

 

That is where the saga began.

 

Disappearance

 

On Oct. 16, 1986, an Israeli F4-Phantom jet streaked through the sky over southern Lebanon. Mr. Arad, then a 28-year-old weapons officer, took aim at a Palestine Liberation Organization target and fired.

 

The bomb detonated prematurely, badly damaging the aircraft. Mr. Arad ejected.

 

Everyone agrees, after years of investigations, that Mr. Arad was captured by a Lebanese Shiite militia and political group known as Amal. The group’s chief of security, Mustafa Dirani, took charge of the fallen airman.

 

The militants offered to trade their hostage for millions of dollars and the release of Palestinian and Lebanese prisoners. But Israel’s defense minister at the time, Yitzhak Rabin, had suffered politically for a prisoner swap in 1985 and was reluctant to make a deal.

 

As progress stalled on locating Mr. Arad, Israeli suspicion fell on Iran and its Shiite Islamic government. It was a reasonable assumption. Iran was a major player in Lebanese politics and provided training and money to Shiite groups, including Amal.

 

In 1989, Mr. Arad’s wife announced that the Israeli government had told her that it had “irrevocable proof” that her husband was alive and that he had been handed over to Iranian operatives.

 

Iranian involvement in Mr. Arad’s disappearance quickly became conventional wisdom, despite Israeli officials’ making no progress in locating him in Iran.

 

An Iranian Doctor With a Story

 

The Iran theory got a major boost in 1992 inside the Mossad.

 

Israel Perlov, a veteran officer, figured that Mr. Arad most likely would have been wounded in his fall and would have needed medical care. Mr. Perlov set out looking for doctors who might have seen the airman.

 

He found an Iranian doctor who claimed to have treated Mr. Arad in both Tehran and Lebanon. This was potentially a breakthrough moment. If the doctor were credible, it would be solid evidence that Mr. Arad had indeed been taken to Iran.

 

But a polygraph test produced inconclusive results on the question of Iran. So Mr. Perlov tested the doctor a second time. Again, the test showed signs of “disturbances” when the doctor described seeing Mr. Arad in Iran.

 

“But they were not significant enough to negate the veracity of his response,” Mr. Perlov wrote in a book released last year.

 

He found the doctor credible, but decided to put the doctor to the test. Mr. Perlov opened a suitcase full of cash and offered it as a reward. All the doctor had to do was prove that he had treated the missing airman.

 

He never saw the doctor again, and Mossad agents never corroborated his story. But Mr. Perlov wrote that his encounters with the doctor bolstered the idea that the “Iranians were up to their necks in holding Ron.”

 

A few years later, another Mossad officer, Rami Igra, would review this encounter and come to a very different conclusion.

 

In his view, Mr. Igra told The Times, the doctor was a liar who had been angling for a big payday. Mr. Igra suspected that the Mossad had gone looking for proof of its own assumption, and found it.

 

But the doctor’s story became part of the official evidence against Iran. Mr. Igra’s contrarian assessment gained little traction.

 

Operation Poisonous Sting

 

The most explosive evidence against Iran burst into public view in 1994, and it shaped public opinion and news accounts for decades.

 

Israeli commandos stormed into Lebanon and kidnapped Mr. Dirani, the militia member who was last known to have held Mr. Arad. They whisked him to an underground prison in an operation known as Poisonous Sting.

 

Under questioning, Mr. Dirani said he had stashed Mr. Arad in a home in the Lebanese village of Nabi Chit, where a trusted family could watch him. One night, he said, the men assigned to guard Mr. Arad had left the house, probably in response to an unrelated Israeli raid nearby. When they returned, he said, Mr. Arad was gone.

 

Years had passed, and Mr. Dirani said he did not know where the airman was.

 

Mr. Dirani’s interrogator did not believe that.

 

“You couldn’t reason with Dirani. The only thing that worked was force,” the interrogator, Doron Zehavi, later recalled in an interview.

 

Mr. Dirani would later testify that he was physically and sexually tortured — claims that the Israeli government broadly denied. But it acknowledged rough treatment and that Mr. Dirani may have been threatened with sexual assault.

 

Under harsh interrogation, Mr. Dirani recounted a meeting with an Iranian official who told him that the Revolutionary Guards had snatched Mr. Arad and taken him to an Iranian prison camp.

 

“After his soul was drained out, when he spat blood, then he tells us about a massive Revolutionary Guards camp complex in Iran,” Mr. Zehavi said.

 

Some believed this as incriminating evidence against the Iranians. Others regarded it as coerced and too unreliable to act on. Mr. Igra, the Mossad officer, concluded that there was no evidence that Iranian officials had held Mr. Arad.

 

To date, no evidence has surfaced to prove Mr. Dirani’s account of Mr. Arad's being held in an Iranian prison, officials say. Some officials believe that Mr. Dirani had honestly recounted his conversation with the Iranian official, but that the information itself was bad.

 

Mr. Igra’s analysis did not conclude what had happened to Mr. Arad. Maybe he had been killed while trying to escape. Perhaps his captors had executed him as revenge in the tit-for-tat fighting that had defined the era.

 

The most logical explanation, he assessed, was that Mr. Arad’s story began and ended in Lebanon. “It was a simple solution to a complex problem,” Mr. Igra said.

 

But Mr. Dirani’s story was big news in Israel. It seemed to confirm years of suspicions that Iran was behind Mr. Arad’s disappearance. Journalists, analysts and top government officials repeated it for years.

 

“The Iranian authorities have been holding Ron Arad for more than six years,” Mr. Rabin said in 1995, “and they are directly and fully responsible for his fate.”

 

Iran Joins the Hunt

 

Convinced that Iran was to blame, the Israeli government put intense pressure on government leaders in Tehran.

 

“The issue of Ron Arad followed us everywhere,” Mohammad Ali Abtahi, Iran’s vice president from 1997 to 2005, told The Times in a telephone interview from Tehran. “In every international encounter we had, we were asked about Ron Arad, Ron Arad.”

 

The case even followed them to the Vatican. When the Iranian president at the time, Mohammad Khatami, visited Rome in 1999, Pope John Paul II presented him with a letter from Mr. Arad’s wife, pleading for information, Mr. Abtahi recalled.

 

“Israel was obsessed about Iran’s role in the Ron Arad case,” he said. “Our position was that this has nothing to do with us. It happened in Lebanon.”

 

Something about that gnawed at some Israeli intelligence officials. Iran knew that Israel would pay a hefty price for information about Mr. Arad. If Iranian leaders possessed such information, why would they not try to capitalize on it?

 

Finally, in 2004, it seemed like that might happen.

 

Israel agreed to free a high-profile Lebanese inmate in exchange for genetic evidence proving what happened to Mr. Arad. Hezbollah’s leader at the time, Hassan Nasrallah, was eager to make that happen, so he enlisted help from the Iranian government.

 

“I got the impression that they — Hezbollah and the Iranians — were truly trying with all their might to locate the body,” Gerhard Conrad, a German intelligence officer who helped mediate the negotiations, told The Times. “Nasrallah knew he could extract any price for him, even if he was dead.”

 

Iran dispatched Abdullah Saberi, a Revolutionary Guards commander who’d served many years in Lebanon, to help coordinate the search, according to former Israeli and Iranian officials.

 

The Hezbollah-Iranian investigation concluded with a secret report saying that Mr. Arad had died in 1988 in Nabi Chit, the village in eastern Lebanon where he had been held, according to three former Iranian officials. The document, the details of which have not been previously reported, concluded that he was most likely buried somewhere there.

 

The findings were considered so important that the former president of Iran Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani, who was involved in the search, dispatched one of his children to Germany to hand-deliver them.

 

“During the entire negotiations, Israel was insisting that we find information on Ron Arad, but we couldn’t find anything,” said Hossein Mousavian, a former Iranian ambassador to Germany.

 

The German mediators saw such high-level engagement as a sign of Iran’s seriousness and willingness to engage.

 

Israel read it completely differently.

 

Why, intelligence officers asked, would Iran have dispatched a Revolutionary Guards commander to lead the search if it had not been involved with the disappearance? To the Israelis, this was evidence of high-level Iranian complicity.

 

“The fact that a highly important Iranian general flew to Lebanon from Tehran to bring a unique body of knowledge and help Hezbollah locate the grave only added to our deep conviction that Iran was behind this event,” Mr. Zimmt, the former intelligence officer who participated in the review, told The Times.

 

Israel’s 2005 report that concluded that Mr. Arad must have been kidnapped by the Revolutionary Guards. (This landmark report remains classified, but its conclusion has been widely reported.)

 

Mr. Zimmt, today a highly regarded scholar who studies Iran, said that looking back, he and his colleagues had gotten tunnel vision. “And it wouldn’t be the last time,” he said.

 

A Killing, Despite Warnings

 

In 2006, Yuval Diskin, the head of Israel’s domestic security agency, Shin Bet, launched a comprehensive review of the Arad case. After two decades without a breakthrough, investigators re-examined every aspect.

 

“We went through everything, item by item, and examined all the sources, their reliability and the way the information had been obtained,” Mr. Diskin told The Times in an interview. “We reached the conclusion that all the reports or analyses based on those reports, according to which Ron Arad had been transferred to or had reached Iran at some stage, were incorrect and were based on serious mistakes in reading the intelligence that had been collected, or on unreliable or erroneous information.”

 

This intelligence assessment was reported earlier by the Israeli journalist Yoav Limor in his 2023 book, “The Interrogator.”

 

The Shin Bet team concluded that Mr. Arad never fell into the hands of Hezbollah or the Revolutionary Guards. The answer to his disappearance, the team said, most likely rested in the village of Nabi Chit — the very place that the Hezbollah-Iranian investigation had pointed to.

 

That report got little traction inside the government, Mr. Diskin said

 

Rather than dropping the Iran theory, the Mossad doubled down with an audacious, and previously unreported, kidnapping operation.

 

A general in the Quds Force of the Revolutionary Guards named Alireza Asgari had been on the Mossad’s radar for years. The general had close ties with Hezbollah leaders and had risen to be deputy Iranian defense minister. Most important, he had arrived in Lebanon shortly after Mr. Arad vanished.

 

In December 2006, General Asgari flew to Istanbul and checked into the Ceylan Hotel, according to his wife, Ziba Ahmadi. From there, he vanished.

 

General Asgari’s disappearance quickly became one of the intelligence world’s biggest whodunits.

 

The Israelis have steadfastly denied involvement.

 

Years later, as the United States and Iran negotiated a nuclear deal and prisoner swaps, the Iranians asked their American counterparts what had happened to their missing general. American officials denied involvement, but quietly began asking questions themselves.

 

Israeli officials told U.S. negotiators that General Asgari was dead, according to a former American official involved in the negotiations. Three other former American officials who worked closely with Israel said that Mossad operatives kidnapped him, interrogated him for weeks and killed him.

 

One of the former officials said that General Asgari had been questioned aboard a boat and dumped into the Black Sea. They said that the Mossad had questioned the general over potential involvement in Mr. Arad’s disappearance. Interrogators had found no such ties.

 

In an interview with The Times, Yitzhak Ilan, a top Shin Bet investigator, recalled a discussion with Mossad officials before General Asgari’s disappearance. Though he did not name the general, he said he had been briefed on a risky intelligence mission related to the airman’s disappearance.

 

“I understood, even before the operation, that the solution was not there at all,” he told The Times before his death in 2020.

 

It is not clear how much the Americans told Iran about what they had learned about General Asgari’s disappearance. Iran conducted its own investigation, and Ms. Ahmadi told The Times that investigators had told her that Israeli operatives had entered her husband’s hotel room, drugged him and kidnapped him.

 

She said that investigators had found the vehicle used in the operation abandoned by the Black Sea.

 

Asked why the Israelis would want to question her husband, she replied, “Have you ever heard of Ron Arad?”

 

More Warnings. Another Abduction.

 

General Asgari’s interrogation had failed to turn up evidence of Mr. Arad’s whereabouts. So once again, officials started from scratch.

 

Mr. Kalo, who led the Israeli military’s missing-in-action unit in 2014, recounted in an interview with The Times how he had examined years of intercepted communications, informant reports and analytical assessments.

 

He reached the same conclusion that the Shin Bet team and the Hezbollah-Iranian investigation had reached years earlier. Mr. Arad had most likely died in 1988, probably in Nabi Chit. He was never in Iran.

 

Mr. Kalo said he delivered his lengthy report to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel in late 2016. The conclusion quickly appeared on Israel’s Channel 2 news.

 

By the time Mr. Kalo retired in 2019, he thought the Iran theory had been laid to rest. In discussions with his colleagues, he recommended focusing future intelligence-gathering on Nabi Chit.

 

Mr. Kalo said he made clear to Israeli intelligence officers that abducting Iranians would not solve the Arad case.

 

But two years later, nearly two decades after he helped coordinate the Hezbollah search for Mr. Arad in Lebanon, General Saberi stepped out of his apartment and ended up inside a refrigerator box and a Mossad moving van.

 

The Israelis never stopped suspecting that General Saberi must know something about the airman’s whereabouts.

 

After a lengthy interrogation, the dazed general was dumped on a street in Johannesburg, South Africa. He later said he was tortured.

 

As questions swirled in Israel, David Barnea, the Mossad chief at the time, said he had authorized an operation to find information on Mr. Arad. He described the mission as “courageous and daring,” but ultimately a “failure.”

 

A Return to the Beginning, at Last

 

After that, Mr. Barnea told Mossad members that they might as well throw everything they knew about the Arad case into the shredder, associates recall.

 

None of the operations, the abductions, the raids or the killings had gotten them closer to finding this missing airman. The Mossad began looking seriously at Nabi Chit.

 

This was the village, Mr. Dirani had told interrogators long ago, where he had stashed Mr. Arad in the care of a trusted family. Those friends had left Mr. Arad alone one night, he had said, to fight Israeli troops nearby.

 

It is also the village that the Hezbollah-Iranian investigation had identified as Mr. Arad’s probable resting place. At least two subsequent Israeli inquiries had reached the same conclusion.

 

One of the few men suspected of knowing Mr. Arad’s location back in 1988, former Israeli and current Lebanese officials said, was Ahmad Shukr, a retired Lebanese security officer. Last December, Mr. Shukr left home for a meeting about what he thought was a business deal.

 

He promptly disappeared, and Lebanese officials believe that he was abducted by Israeli agents. Mr. Shukr’s whereabouts remains a mystery, as does what he may have told investigators.

 

Israeli officials now say that the closest thing the government has to a theory is that Mr. Arad was executed as retribution for the killing of Mr. Shukr’s brother, who died battling Israeli forces that night in 1988. (Ahmad Shukr’s niece Rana Shukr said in an interview that her uncle had nothing to do with Mr. Arad.)

 

A few months after Mr. Shukr’s disappearance, Israeli soldiers descended on Nabi Chit in one of the deadliest clashes of this latest round of fighting with Hezbollah. Dozens of Lebanese were killed and wounded.

 

Israeli soldiers searched a corner of a cemetery, looking for the remains of Mr. Arad, and unearthed a grave. They found nothing, but officials say that the search continues — with a focus now on Lebanon rather than Iran.

 

“We should have gone there 20 years ago. It was a failure,” Mr. Kalo said. “We could not get away from the narrative that Iran was involved. We could not untie Arad from the threat of Iran. It was too deeply rooted in our obsession.”

 

Gal Koplewitz and Euan Ward contributed reporting.


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


2) ‘Birdbrain’ Is a Misnomer. Crows Make Decisions Faster Than We Can

In a recent experiment, crows could process and respond to visual cues at twice the speed as humans and monkeys.

By Taylor Mitchell Brown, Nov. 15, 2026

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/15/science/birdbrain-crows-birds-research-decision.html

A crow stands facing a screen with a circle of dots shown on it.

In an experiment, a crow was asked to decide whether a certain number of white dots on a screen moved simultaneously to the left or to the right, pecking at the corresponding target circle on the monitor. Andreas Nieder


Lemmy and Iggy, two carrion crows, are no strangers to a psychology lab. As study participants, they have helped scientists prove that birds can use tools to forage, learn numbers and count objects, and provided other insights into the ways birds think.

 

Now, they’ve also revealed that birds can make staggeringly quick decisions, besting their human and nonhuman primate counterparts with ease. In new findings published in Science, the crows could process and respond to visual cues at twice the speed as humans and monkeys, quantifying the neural speed of avian decision-making for the first time.

 

The discovery might be the final blow for the use of “birdbrains” as a pejorative.

 

“We wouldn’t think of birds making these decisions faster than monkeys, or faster than us ‘awesome’ human beings,” said Mike Colombo, a neuroscientist and comparative psychologist at the University of Otago in New Zealand who was not involved in the research. “But they do. They’re just incredibly fast.”

 

Questions of bird intelligence have long been debated by researchers. Their small and superficially simple brains led scholars in the 19th and much of the 20th century to conclude they were not cognitively competent creatures. Even early research into birdsong, which demonstrated that some birds are capable of complex speech-like patterns and impressive vocal mimicry, was not enough to turn the tide. Their elaborate melodies were considered specialized adaptations that didn’t reflect their cognitive abilities.

 

Although passionate birders may find those conclusions obviously mistaken, the scientific community has been slower to catch on. “It’s taken the last 20 years to realize that actually their brain architecture is quite fascinating,” said Dr. Colombo.

 

Recent research, for example, has found that pigeons are capable of distinguishing between cancerous and noncancerous cells, numerical values, and words and non-words. Corvids (the group that includes crows, ravens, rooks and scrub jays) can even recognize themselves, solve abstract problems, plan for the future and show theory of mind — an ability to understand what other birds might be thinking and act accordingly.

 

For the new study, researchers at the University of Tübingen in Germany wanted to better understand how crows make decisions, so they set up an experiment to record their brain activity as the birds performed a visual task. After several weeks of training — and countless mealworm treats — Lemmy and Iggy learned to peck left or right to match the orientation of flashing white dots on a black screen.

 

During the experiment, the dots would randomly orient facing left or right. Sometimes a majority of the dots would align in one direction, making the task easy. Other times, only a small percentage would change, making it difficult. The crows’ objective was to peck the screen to match the orientation of the dots; at the same time, their neural activity was recorded by electrodes.

 

The researchers were particularly interested in the area of a bird’s brain called the nidopallium caudolaterale, which is comparable to the prefrontal cortex in primates. The prefrontal cortex is “the C.E.O. in our brain,” said Andreas Nieder, a neurophysiologist at the University of Tübingen and an author of the study. It’s responsible for many of our more cognitively complex abilities, including planning, working memory and abstract thinking. So activity in the comparable region might yield crucial insight into bird smarts.

 

The crows were allowed three seconds to make their decisions, but the results revealed they needed less than one. They reliably pecked their answers in about 235 milliseconds, which is twice as fast as rhesus monkeys or humans when performing similar experiments. Moreover, they pecked their decisions at breakneck speeds without compromising accuracy. “This was a result that we didn’t anticipate,” Dr. Nieder said.

 

To ensure the results weren’t a fluke, Dr. Nieder retested the crows and then turned to verify the methodology on every person he could get his hands on. “I think we tested all the people in my lab,” he said. But his undergraduate, Ph.D. and postdoctoral participants were no match for the crows.

 

The work underscores how the avian brain, despite its diminutive size, is tuned for rapid processing.

 

When comparing a crow’s nidopallium caudolaterale with a rhesus monkey’s prefrontal cortex, for instance, there are nearly the same number of neurons crammed into a smaller space. “So the bird brains are actually anatomically wired much more efficiently,” said Michael Griesser, a biologist and bird behavior expert at the University of Konstanz in Germany who was not involved with the research.

 

The Tübingen team suspects the ability to make such quick decisions might have evolved in response to the risky world of flight, where the difference between quickly or slowly reacting to something in the field of vision could be the difference between a smooth flight and crashing, or missing out on food.

 

Ultimately, the work is changing what it means to have a ‘birdbrain,’ or, as Dr. Colombo called it, an “incredibly efficient machine.”


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


3) By Zachary D. Carter, Nov. 16, 2026

Mr. Carter is the author of “The Price of Peace: Money, Democracy and the Life of John Maynard Keynes.”


“When any financial mania ends, the public shoulders the costs. Crushed stock markets erase savings and ravage job prospects. And when the government has to deploy taxpayer dollars to bail out, say, a major bank that got in over its skis, there’s less money around to fill the potholes, pay for the bus drivers or fund struggling schools. Almost everything working families rely on in daily life gets worse after a financial crisis, and the effects linger for decades in the form of lost earnings and family lives turned upside down by unemployment. … A.I. optimists tend to spend a lot of time talking about how the technology will cure cancer or end poverty — an acknowledgment that A.I. is a means to other advances that actually matter to people. If you follow the money, however, Silicon Valley is far more focused on generating more computing power, in the belief, held by some, that it will give A.I. superhuman abilities that will fix all of our problems. Not everyone agrees with that belief. Major A.I. executives can’t even agree on what A.I. is. (Most do seem to agree that they should not be liable for crimes committed with their new tools.)”


https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/16/opinion/ai-bubble-finance-crisis-deregulation.html

A photorealistic illustration of a young man in a yellow T-shirt, back to the viewer and arms raised. A large meteor-shaped blob containing old computer screens, pieces of computer hardware and houses careens toward him.

Danielle Del Plato


It wasn’t too long ago that Silicon Valley was celebrating the greatest invention in economic history. A dazzling new medium called cryptocurrency had arrived — at once an extraordinary investment, a government-proof digital money and perhaps a way to bring world peace. It would end global poverty and cure inflation. The possibilities were endless — until the public face of the crypto revolution landed in federal prison and the American president began winning his family millions through Trump-branded crypto schemes.

 

Cryptocurrency still exists, though few take seriously the grandiose promises of yesteryear. As the public’s enthusiasm for digital currency faded, some of its most prominent boosters began showering praise on another shiny object: The artificial intelligence universe is just lousy with crypto players. A.I. “is our alchemy, our Philosopher’s Stone — we are literally making sand think,” trumpeted Marc Andreessen, whose firm has been one of the most influential crypto and A.I. players over the past decade.

 

Of course, the extreme prognostications about artificial intelligence aren’t exactly like the woo-woo crypto hype of 2020. A.I. already has some genuinely useful applications in software development. It might even blow up the world! Maybe that’s why Silicon Valley’s hype machine has been so successful at turning the economy into a massive one-way bet on delivering a still undefined type of “superintelligence” to the globe. Last year, according to the St. Louis Fed, nearly 40 percent of American economic growth came from the A.I. build-out.

 

These days, however, excitement is mutating into anxiety. A major A.I.-themed hedge fund collapsed over the summer. Days ago, shares of the A.I. chip giant Nvidia plummeted upon the abrupt resignation of its megawatt chief executive amid allegations of extramarital affairs with a Chinese spy and two women who reported to him. Whatever technological changes may lie in store, the bigger picture is starting to look a lot like a movie we’ve seen before — wild promises and warnings, unusual financing arrangements and the collapse of highflying adventurers. One of our newest industries is following a highly familiar script: The A.I. build-out has become so dependent on the riskiest lending practices of Wall Street that Silicon Valley itself might now be better understood as a wild, unregulated division of the banking sector.

 

If you haven’t seen this movie, it usually ends in a mess: the 2008 financial crisis, or the collapse of railway mania in 1840s Britain that spurred an industrial depression, or the Panic of 1873 that caused a global catastrophe so bad they called it the Great Depression until that other one came along.

 

When financial history repeats, fatalism can be hard to resist. It is genuinely disheartening to see people pitch and fall for farcical nonsense, time after time. But our present is not simply repeating the recent past — in important ways, the cycle is getting worse.

 

Since the 1980s, the United States government has been subjecting more and more of the national economy to the risks of runaway finance. When any financial mania ends, the public shoulders the costs. Crushed stock markets erase savings and ravage job prospects. And when the government has to deploy taxpayer dollars to bail out, say, a major bank that got in over its skis, there’s less money around to fill the potholes, pay for the bus drivers or fund struggling schools. Almost everything working families rely on in daily life gets worse after a financial crisis, and the effects linger for decades in the form of lost earnings and family lives turned upside down by unemployment.

 

Sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter  Get expert analysis of the news and a guide to the big ideas shaping the world every weekday morning.

 

It doesn’t have to be this way. Or at least, it doesn’t have to be this bad. About 90 years ago, the economist John Maynard Keynes observed that monetary markets are inherently preoccupied with stories about the future. We save money to spend it later; we spend now to build and attain the things our future selves will appreciate. Keynes realized that attempts to calculate the future value of an investment accurately would require a level of certainty about the future that human beings do not possess. Sometimes things just happen — strange wars, senile presidents — you never know. Financial judgments are thus inevitably susceptible to the “animal spirits” of human psychology, carrying “only a little more” scientific precision than predictions about “an expedition to the South Pole.”

 

But Keynes insisted that while there may be no perfect economic system, there are degrees of dysfunction. The more a nation’s economy — be it based on manufacturing home appliances or on developing software — is absorbed by the vagaries of its financial functions, the more prone it will be to financial calamity.

 

At a time when valuations for A.I. firms like Anthropic are rising into the trillions, the American government is pouring gas on the fire. President Trump has been heralding massive A.I. spending as the economic future, before championing the coming of a “Supreme Intelligence” (since modified to “Super Intelligence,” his preferred term of art). Mr. Trump loves a soaring stock market and understands that the stock market is currently running on A.I. spirits — more than a third of the entire value of all U.S. equities is now subsumed under A.I. stocks. By late summer, tech stocks accounted for more than half the value of the S&P 500.

 

Not every stock market crash ends in a Great Depression, but the 1929 crash did. That experience persuaded the American government to implement a strict legal separation between financial activities and the rest of the economy — you couldn’t run a manufacturing operation that was also a bank. You couldn’t even run a bank that was also speculating in the stock market; these businesses had to be independently operated and regulated in order to isolate financial contagions, and to protect other economic sectors from the risks inherent to finance. And between the 1930s and the 1970s, this program basically worked. The catastrophic cycle of boom and bust that had plagued the American banking sector since the Civil War came to an end.

 

In the 1980s, however, President Ronald Reagan ushered in a fundamental redesign of the American economy. There hadn’t been a serious bank crash for decades, and Reagan was convinced that post-Depression regulations and other government red tape were to blame for the rampant inflation and grim productivity that dogged the 1970s. The marching orders were clear: Decentralize government oversight, and unleash the power of American profit.

 

These changes were not merely legal — they transformed the culture of the economy. For decades, bank executives had been the helpmates of heavy industry, living by the “3-6-3” mantra: borrow at 3 percent, lend at 6 percent, and hit the golf course by 3 p.m. Now they were to be masters of the universe, commanding the American economy from the skyscraper on down, disciplining bloated industry and complacent labor with the relentless drive for lower costs and higher profits. The earth-toned images of crime families and crooked cops that had dominated the late 1970s sharpened into the slicked-back icons of best sellers such as “The Bonfire of the Vanities” and “Liar’s Poker” and the director Oliver Stone’s “Wall Street.”

 

By the end of the 1990s, it seemed like nobody could imagine an economy pushed onward by anything other than the wolves of Wall Street. When Bill Clinton reviewed his presidential achievements in his 2004 memoir, he didn’t even mention two major financial deregulation bills he had signed into law with overwhelming bipartisan support. Finance was fundamental; financialization was just how the world worked.

 

The dismantling of Depression-era firewalls has predictably been accompanied by banking crises. As the 1980s turned to the 1990s, over a thousand ordinary savings and loans failed — roughly a third of the entire sector. Private equity firms had seized on new Reagan-era rules to turn these local lenders into dumping grounds for ultra-high-risk debt.

 

A decade later, executives at previously staid banks like Wells Fargo, Citigroup and Bank of America were enjoying new abilities to cross state lines and storm into the insurance and securities businesses. Once regional operations exploded into multisector international behemoths whose byzantine exposures were all but impossible to track, let alone manage. Even General Motors, the nation’s largest auto company, began exploiting various legal avenues to transform itself into one of the nation’s largest mortgage lenders, a move facilitated by a 1997 Utah state law allowing the company to operate its own full-fledged bank. It was an open mockery of the wall between finance and commerce that had been built after the Depression. Federal regulators looked the other way — until the financial crisis. By 2010, the U.S. Treasury had devoted $17.2 billion to rescuing G.M.’s bank, and $49.5 billion to save General Motors. Congress authorized hundreds of billions of dollars to help save the rest of the nation’s financial system, with trillions more in emergency lending from the Federal Reserve.

 

All of these debacles resulted in privileged insiders’ reaping enormous rewards while ordinary Americans were called in to clean up the mess. Banks dependent on public support paid out billions of dollars in bonuses to their top executives. The national unemployment rate hit 10 percent.

 

Financialization changed American institutions and altered the national culture of work and reward. Today, roughly one in four young men in America trades stocks on a daily basis; a similar percentage of young men gamble on a daily basis. Most of them, according to a conservative think tank, “feel like failures.” The, ahem, traditional sports betting industry in the United States scored record revenues of nearly $17 billion last year — never mind the growth of the indistinguishable activity at new sites called prediction markets, which are moving $24 billion a month globally.

 

Dudes have more time to trade these days: Between 1980 and 2000, the United States lost about two million manufacturing jobs. Mr. Clinton didn’t just deregulate finance; he attacked domestic industry by signing the North American Free Trade Agreement into law and welcoming China into the World Trade Organization. As a share of the U.S. economy, today’s financial sector is roughly triple the size of its post-World War II nadir — but even this figure is difficult to estimate, because so much financial activity has been subsumed into the tech world itself, with trillions of dollars in investment now hanging in the balance.

 

Everywhere you look in 2026, multitrillion-dollar tech companies are storming into the financial world. Meta and Apple now move funds for digital shoppers around the world, while Amazon and Apple pitch credit cards. Nvidia, the country’s largest computer chip manufacturer, is also a major lender to the A.I. industry and its insatiable hunger for cash, approving $500 billion worth of partnerships with big banks and private equity firms. Nvidia doesn’t just make and sell the chips that power the A.I. revolution. It also invests in the data centers that power the technology, and is partnering with OpenAI and other A.I. developers to provide hundreds of billions of dollars in additional financing for still more A.I.-related projects.

 

Nvidia is even in talks with insurance companies to insure these loans against default. This should sound familiar: In the early 2000s, big banks turned to the insurer A.I.G. to protect themselves against losses on risky mortgage bonds. But when home prices crashed, A.I.G. collapsed, risking the viability of Goldman Sachs, Citigroup, Wells Fargo and others. Insurance did not alleviate financial risk — it loaded an extra layer of financial risk atop the market, amplifying dangers rather than reducing them.

 

Whether Nvidia can, in fact, secure an insurer remains to be seen. But the impulse is revealing. By operating as a lender, Nvidia is already injecting the instability of Wall Street directly into what has become the most economically critical manufacturing operation in the country — as a matter of standard corporate policy. How fitting that the executor of many of Nvidia’s aggressive financial moves, the chief financial officer, Colette Kress, has just been named its interim chief executive; the company’s financial maneuvers may be as critical to its future as its physical products.

 

Nvidia isn’t propping up the sector alone. A multitrillion-dollar sub-industry of “private credit” — a term of art for loans made beyond the purview of traditional financial regulations — has ballooned at the nation’s largest banks and private equity firms. And this shadow market just happens to specialize in hard-to-value projects related to A.I. and data centers.

 

The candle is burning from both ends. Wealthy individuals are increasingly relying on tech stocks as collateral for loans that are propping up our economy — loans to buy real estate, or cars, or even more tech stocks. A tech blowup could thus easily disrupt lending to other sectors of the economy: Mess with either the A.I. build-out or its increasingly fragile financial underpinnings, and both will be in trouble. They are already in many respects the same entity.

 

In other countries, innovation isn’t so heavily focused on A.I. China is investing in A.I. too, but it is accompanying its computer push with $2.2 trillion a year in green tech investment that is about strengthening manufacturing prowess rather than pure processing power. China has been developing better solar panels, more powerful wind farms, more efficient batteries and a new generation of electric vehicles. These innovations have their own stories to tell about the future, but there is an important difference between promising to improve something that already exists — say, a car, an effort that adds jobs — and vowing to change the technological foundation of all work without a plan. In the United States, the bulk of A.I. spending goes into building data centers with temporary local benefits; once they’re built, the construction jobs are gone, while the tax incentives deployed to get them constructed drain resources from state and local governments.

 

It is folly to hope the Trump administration will do anything to avert an A.I.-driven financial crisis. The administration is not only encouraging the tech industry’s leap into the turbulent waves of finance; it is helping car manufacturers get back into banking, too. In January, about 17 years after our government was forced to bail out G.M.’s bank, the Trump administration approved applications from Ford and G.M. to open new banks, headquartered in Salt Lake City.

 

This is probably going to hurt all of us, and managing the fallout from a crash is as much art as science. How we ought to structure the economy going forward, however, has been clear since the Great Depression: Don’t let big business merge with big finance. Our government needs to hold big tech and big finance accountable for operating deeply uncertain businesses with vast public consequences. We need smaller, simpler tech companies that support American industry rather than dominating it.

 

A.I. optimists tend to spend a lot of time talking about how the technology will cure cancer or end poverty — an acknowledgment that A.I. is a means to other advances that actually matter to people. If you follow the money, however, Silicon Valley is far more focused on generating more computing power, in the belief, held by some, that it will give A.I. superhuman abilities that will fix all of our problems. Not everyone agrees with that belief. Major A.I. executives can’t even agree on what A.I. is. (Most do seem to agree that they should not be liable for crimes committed with their new tools.)

 

Better computers can help with all kinds of things, but you can’t cure cancer with data centers alone. As with the pandemic-era crypto boom, A.I. has let its stories about the future run so far ahead of economic reality, the ultimate project starts to look like sweeping economic change for the sake of sweeping economic change. There are better futures to bet on.


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


4) The Eat-What-You-Kill System That Rules Big Law

By John C. Coffee Jr., Nov. 16, 2026

Mr. Coffee is a professor of law at Columbia University Law School and director of its Center on Corporate Governance.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/16/opinion/big-law-firms-competition.html

An illustration of three gavels pounding each other and breaking.

Benny Douet


Major law firms in the United States seem to be enjoying a golden age. Partners’ individual compensation is well into the millions — star partners may make $20 to $30 million annually — and even first-year lawyers earn $250,000 at top New York City firms.

 

Then, in October, the well-known firm of Weil, Gotshal & Manges announced that it would dissolve, an implosion that shocked the bar. Unlike other firms that have collapsed, Weil was large (about 1,200 lawyers), highly respected and scandal free. Yet its own leadership surrendered, and stopped trying to save this 95-year old firm.

 

Why? Let’s begin with the fact that law firms are composed of often contentious persons (called lawyers) who are inclined to argue their positions aggressively. These disputes — typically about compensation or control issues — can produce rivalries and bitterness, but they have virtually never been the primary reason a major firm voluntarily dissolved itself.

 

The Weil implosion highlights the new internal stresses destabilizing large law firms today, making them look more like collections of free agents — many of whom are waiting for a better offer to lure them away. Firms not only have to compete zealously at practicing law, but also at holding a highly mobile team together — much as if every player on the Dodgers or Yankees were a free agent who could leave tomorrow.

 

Increasingly, compensation packages for partners reflect the principle of eat what you kill, and the once-respected ideals such as firm culture, the community of the partnership and a commitment to pro bono work and public service are recognized more in rhetoric then in practice. Particularly for young lawyers, the future looks foreboding as artificial intelligence reduces the need for humans in the handling of routine legal work.

 

In the past, big law firms maintained stability by offering all partners with the same seniority equal compensation. It was inefficient but broadcast the message that the partnership was a band of equals, each committed to the firm’s advancement.

 

Similarly, the best firms normally did not recruit partners from the outside, preferring to promote their own associates. Loyalty to the firm was the paramount value, on par with family loyalty.

 

Until it wasn’t. The culture of big law began to change with the rise of corporate takeovers in the 1980s, which led to an exponential growth in the profitability of law firms that had expertise in mergers and acquisitions. Not only did new firms enter the game and increase competition, but as the names of the star partners became well known, job mobility quickly followed. For large firms, the logic of paying big money to acquire star lawyers was a no-brainer that mirrored the deals they were working on: It offered a high return on investment.

 

Just as a free agent baseball slugger can become the subject of an auction, so too has the star partner become a very valuable acquisition target. The Dodgers won back-to-back World Series by hiring extraordinary and expensive free agent players.

 

Correspondingly, major law firms greatly improved their position and profitability by raiding rival firms. In 2016, Paul, Weiss hired the star M&A specialist Scott Barshay from Cravath, Swaine & Moore. If Cravath, for a century the iconic model for the large law firm, could be raided, no firm was safe.

 

Today, the firm leading the free agent pursuit is Kirkland & Ellis. So far this year it has reportedly added 119 new partners from outside the firm, but seen 224 depart. This is a head-spinning turnover rate that, as in baseball, means you can’t tell the partners without a scorecard.

 

The analogy between baseball and law has its limits. If a firm experiences multiple departures, a panic can ensue. Weil, Gotshal may have been in just such an exposed position. When a team of six Weil partners departed for (ironically) Cravath in September, the race was on for the others to find new homes. As in a bank run, getting out first is the best strategy.

 

In the world of law, the risks are far higher than in baseball. Dewey & LeBoeuf was a better known firm than Weil. In 2012, it filed for bankruptcy after more than half the firm’s partners resigned when they learned that their managing partners had borrowed some $245 million, in part to grant guaranteed multi-million-dollar contracts to lure or retain more than 100 free agents and existing partners.

 

In the wake of the 2008 financial crisis, the firm was unable to honor these contracts. The Manhattan district attorney indicted three Dewey executives for defrauding their partners and lenders. Dewey’s demise signaled that even law firms like Weil can come apart at the seams under competitive pressure.

 

While A.I. doesn’t seem to have played a role in the dissolution of Weil, Gotshal, it could force a major industry restructuring. A.I. may enable firms to reduce the number of young lawyers they hire, because A.I. can easily perform the more perfunctory legal tasks that are assigned to associates. The legal profession has long had a lengthy seven- or eight-year apprenticeship before deciding which associates make partner. As young lawyers become less valuable, the investment in such development programs may decline.

 

Another loss hasn’t made headlines: the civic engagement that was part of the culture of many big firms. The big law partnership may be moving in the direction of a harsher, less equal environment in which less tolerance is shown for those who want to combine idealism and legal practice. That would be a societal loss, as there is a long history of constitutional law being shaped by lawyers in private practice motivated by idealism and a sense of justice.

 

We are watching competition at work, and the legal industry can benefit from that, just as any other industry does. But it might be better served if firms do more conscious planning about firm culture. So go ahead and hire superstars at an inflated salary. Then assure other partners who are interested that they can do pro bono and test case work. Keep in mind that a number of partners have recently left Paul, Weiss and a common denominator in their departures appears to have been a sense that the firm’s culture had changed.

 

There is no chance that law firms will go back to lock step compensation policy; they will continue to eat what they kill. The bidding for free agents will continue because it has increased profits at the firms that have used it most. With their leverage increased, the free agent partners may demand both greater compensation and a more dominant voice within their firms.

 

Still, one factor may constrain these developments: Firms that persist in encouraging public service and civil liberties litigation may earn the reputational credit that attracts the best young lawyers to them. We must recognize that law firm partnerships are something like marriages: Each is a little different. Any attempt to make them all alike is ill-advised, but each partnership must plan its future carefully — or risk a Weil, Gotshal-like debacle.


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


5) Carbon Emissions of Biggest U.S. Data Centers Already Rival Entire Countries, Study Reveals

By Harry Stevens, Nov. 16, 2026


“The largest data centers in the United States are responsible for an estimated 25.7 million metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions annually — almost as much as entire countries like Bolivia or Denmark — according to new research. … As the number of users grows, so will the carbon footprint. While the study represents the most thorough accounting to date of data centers’ emissions and electricity consumption, it is also already outdated: Since the study period ended on May 1, 2025, at least 250 more data centers have come online, according to Cleanview’s data.”


https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/11/16/climate/ai-data-center-pollution-carbon-emissions.html

A drone view of a data center under construction.A drone view shows construction underway on Microsoft’s data center in Union City, Ga. Credit...Brian Snyder/Reuters


The largest data centers in the United States are responsible for an estimated 25.7 million metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions annually — almost as much as entire countries like Bolivia or Denmark — according to new research.

 

The study, published Monday in the journal Nature Sustainability, delivers the first peer-reviewed estimates of carbon dioxide emissions from the country’s biggest data centers since the start of the artificial intelligence boom. Its authors, a team led by researchers from Harvard University, examined the electricity consumption and carbon emissions of 403 data centers from May 2024 to April 2025.

 

All told, those data centers used almost 2 percent of U.S. electricity, more than New York City and Los Angeles combined, and represented about 0.5 percent of U.S. carbon dioxide emissions. Carbon dioxide is the primary greenhouse gas driving global warming.

 

Data centers in just three states, Virginia, Iowa and Ohio, accounted for about half of the emissions estimated in the study. In states like Oregon, data centers are responsible for emitting less carbon dioxide per unit of electricity consumed because a larger share of their power is generated without fossil fuels, the study found.

 

Across all 403 facilities, 54 percent of the electricity came from burning fossil fuels, mostly natural gas and coal.

 

Much of the analysis in the study amounted to detective work, underscoring the secrecy under which A.I. companies have been allowed to operate. Without a public list of data centers to work with, the researchers began by consulting a commercial dataset whose licensing rules prevented them — and The New York Times — from publishing facilities’ addresses, names and owners.

 

The researchers spent hours studying building footprints and satellite imagery to confirm the location and size of data centers, estimated how much electricity they could use and then calculated their emissions based on the mix of power plants supplying each regional electricity grid.

 

“The fact that we had to go through such an extensive reconstruction process just to understand where the infrastructure is and how large it is tells you something about the lack of transparency itself in the industry,” said Gianluca Guidi, the Harvard scientist who led the research team.

 

Michael Thomas, who runs the energy data company Cleanview and was not involved with the study, drew a contrast between data centers and power plants, which are required to publicly report all sorts of details about the environmental effects of their operations. Collecting the details of data center operations, on the other hand, requires sifting through millions of documents scattered across county, state and federal databases.

 

“We’ve had, like, a half dozen senators reach out to us. They’re like, ‘How many data centers are there? We’re trying to write a bill,’” Mr. Thomas said. “Why is the Senate reaching out to me and not E.I.A. or FERC?” he added, using abbreviations for the U.S. Energy Information Administration and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.

 

While states like Virginia and Ohio have begun moving toward stricter oversight, Dr. Guidi said the federal government should require the operators of large data centers to publicly disclose their electricity use and emissions.

 

“Communities shouldn’t need a team of Harvard researchers to analyze satellite images to understand their environmental impact,” he said.

 

Data center developers have multiple tools at their disposal to obfuscate the carbon and energy effects of their projects. Those layers of secrecy have emerged as a major point of concern in the growing resistance to data center projects nationwide. Voters opted to limit or prevent data center development in 40 of 41 relevant local ballot initiatives in this month’s midterm elections.

 

“Non-disclosure agreements, hidden end users, and closed-door negotiations frame opposition narratives more consistently than any other concern,” according to a recent report by Relae, a climate and energy consultancy.

 

Between March 2024 and early November 2026, local opposition has blocked or delayed at least 70 A.I. data center projects across 25 states, representing an estimated $271 billion in investment, according to Relae’s research.

 

Fourteen of those projects were in Virginia, the heart of the data center boom. Virginia’s data centers accounted for more than a quarter of the emissions estimated in the study. In PJM Interconnection, the regional grid operator serving Virginia, about 60 percent of the electricity powering data centers is produced by fossil fuels.

 

The figures in the study likely underestimate all U.S. data center emissions because the list of facilities it examined does not represent a complete inventory. It excludes hundreds of possible data centers the researchers could not sufficiently verify, as well as facilities that bypass the grid by drawing power from on-site generators.

 

It is also a snapshot of an industry growing at breakneck speed. The average facility in the study had an electrical capacity of about 40 megawatts, whereas upcoming projects, such as Meta’s 5-gigawatt Hyperion campus in Louisiana, will have more than 100 times that capacity.

 

Still, outside researchers said the study provides a crucial baseline for understanding the climate change implications of the A.I. buildout.

 

“It resets our understanding of these large data centers that are already operating, that they use maybe more power and emit more greenhouse gas emissions than we had thought,” said Eric Masanet, who researches emerging environmental technologies at the University of California, Santa Barbara.

 

Whether data centers’ growing greenhouse gas emissions represent an acceptable environmental cost should hinge on how useful A.I. proves to be, said Andy Masley, an independent researcher who analyzes the environmental effects of data centers.

 

“I don’t really think it makes sense to look at an industry and just say, ‘Oh, because it’s growing and it’s going to make up a meaningful percentage share of American emissions, that must mean it’s bad,’” Mr. Masley said. “Part of the reason they’re emitting so much is just that they’re being used by so many people.”

 

As the number of users grows, so will the carbon footprint. While the study represents the most thorough accounting to date of data centers’ emissions and electricity consumption, it is also already outdated: Since the study period ended on May 1, 2025, at least 250 more data centers have come online, according to Cleanview’s data.


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


6) Five European Countries Plan to Deport Migrants to Rwanda

Germany, Austria, the Netherlands, Greece and Denmark are seeking to establish a hub for rejected asylum seekers. Here’s what to know about their effort.

By Jeanna Smialek and Koba Ryckewaert, Reporting from Brussels, Nov. 16, 2026

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/16/world/europe/deport-rwanda-asylum-migration.html

A row of suited officials standing behind a row of small circular tables bearing miniature flags.

Ministers from the Five Country Group, which includes Austria, Germany, Denmark, the Netherlands and Greece, after a meeting on immigration and integration in Copenhagen in September. Liselotte Sabroe/Ritzau Scanpix, via Agence France-Presse — Getty Images


Five European countries announced a plan on Monday that would send rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda, an experiment that comes as governments across the continent toughen their stances on migration.

 

The joint push from Germany, Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands and Greece was pitched as a way to handle migrants who had no right to stay in Europe but who, for one reason or another, could not or would not return to their home countries.

 

The project, which is not yet finalized, shows how European leaders’ stance on migration has hardened since the arrivals of 2015-16, when countries like Germany admitted more than a million asylum seekers. With far-right groups like the Alternative for Germany rising in popularity, centrist leaders have gradually taken a less welcoming stance.

 

“For me, today marks a crucial step toward a new migration system,” Mette Frederiksen, the prime minister of Denmark, said at a news conference on Monday.

 

The pilot project is expected to start on a small scale, with perhaps 100 or 200 deportees. Critics are already worried both about the idea of sending people to a nation to which they have no connection, and about the risk that human rights will not be sufficiently protected in Rwanda.

 

Why Rwanda?

 

The country has a history of courting migration-related deals.

 

Britain developed a plan to send asylum seekers there in 2022, though judges in London ultimately ruled the effort unlawful and it was later abandoned. The United States has recently deported people to Rwanda.

 

This is not Europe’s first experiment in funneling migrants toward third countries. Italy tried to set up an asylum processing hub in Albania, though that plan has run into legal challenges.

 

The five countries involved in this plan argue that it is different from previous efforts. For one thing, it will focus on migrants who have exhausted their legal avenues for staying in Europe, rather than on migrants who are just starting asylum claims. The European Union recently set out a legal framework for third-country return hubs, and this one will be operated along those lines.

 

But the decision has raised eyebrows.

 

Critics object to the choice of destination.

 

For some, the choice of Rwanda is concerning. The nation often ranks low on human rights measures, especially when it comes to free speech. It has also faced sanctions from the United States and criticism from Europe, which have accused it of supporting a rebel militia in the Democratic Republic of Congo.

 

“Its human rights record is very, very dodgy,” said Toni Haastrup, professor and chair in global politics at the University of Manchester.

 

Mélissa Camara, a member of European Parliament, objects to return hubs as a concept, saying they did not do enough to guarantee human rights. On Monday, she called the Rwanda plan “an agreement of shame, a grave moral failing.”

 

Will this time be different?

 

The nations leading the charge insist that human rights will be protected. And they say that deporting people to Rwanda could bring big benefits, including discouraging future immigrants.

 

And Rwanda’s history of negotiating deals of this kind makes it easier to work with, said Alberto‑Horst Neidhardt, head of the migration program at the European Policy Center, a think tank.

 

“It meets some of the basic criteria,” he said. “Plus, there’s a precedent, so the taboo has been broken.”

 

Of course, attempts to put migrant centers in third countries have run into roadblocks. The British plan involving Rwanda did not compulsorily deport anyone, and cost Britain nearly $1 billion before it tanked.

 

Supporters say the new five-country program will meet a need.

 

“They don’t have a legal ground to be here,” Morten Bodskov, Denmark’s minister for immigration and integration, told reporters last month, speaking of the migrants being targeted. “The return hub model is an answer to that.”

 

The European Union has indicated that the program has the bloc’s support.

 

The project has come after “careful preparatory work, including with regard to ensuring the respect for human rights,” Markus Lammert, a spokesman for the E.U. executive, said on Monday.


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


7) Americans Are Worried About More Than Prices

By Astra Taylor, Nov. 16, 2026

Ms. Taylor is a contributing Opinion writer and an author of “End Times Fascism.”


“The tone of these midterms was set by ordinary people who stuck their necks out by bravely opposing Elon Musk, immigration enforcement, data centers and the carnage in Gaza well before those positions were safely mainstream. … That’s what real economic populism is: a democratic revolt against the capture and corruption of politics by moneyed interests, which is more than just a call for lower living costs. It is also fully compatible with a politics that refuses to pull punches about the far right’s authoritarian designs, and is inseparable from universal human rights. … The midterms showed that a growing number of people, from all walks of life, want to be able to make ends meet. They also showed that ordinary people understand that the stakes are much more existential. This is a fight for a livable democratic future that we can’t afford to lose.”


https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/16/opinion/affordability-midterms-voters.html

An illustration of a fist atop people’s legs.

Nathaniel Russell


As we process the Democratic Party’s midterm victory, a widely agreed-upon narrative is emerging: This was an affordability election. From South Carolina to Ohio to California, voters rallied behind Democratic candidates who spoke to kitchen-table concerns.

 

But it would be wrong, and ultimately dangerous, to interpret voters’ preference for Democrats exclusively as a reaction to rising prices.

 

This election was also a profoundly antifascist one.

 

Americans desperately want and need costs to come down, and delivering on that should be the Democratic Party’s first priority. But the landslide that redrew political maps, particularly in the South, cannot be explained solely by anger at grocery and gasoline prices. It was also powered by a deep sense of moral revulsion and indignation that has only gained force since 2024.

 

The tone of these midterms was set by ordinary people who stuck their necks out by bravely opposing Elon Musk, immigration enforcement, data centers and the carnage in Gaza well before those positions were safely mainstream.

 

Let’s remember how, in the early days of the second Trump administration, an atmosphere of fear descended over the nation as many elite institutions — universities, law firms, media outlets and tech companies — bent the knee, convinced that a permanent proto-fascist “vibe shift” had arrived. Thankfully, not everyone was so eager to acquiesce.

 

Soon after the inauguration, Tesla Takedown protests popped up at Tesla dealerships and spread widely, much to the irritation of Elon Musk, who was then gleefully beginning to gut the federal work force. People kept showing up even after President Trump threatened to classify those who vandalized Tesla cars as “domestic terrorists” and send them to Salvadoran prisons.

 

In April 2025, according to organizers of the events, millions of people at 1,400 sites across the country mobilized during the Hands Off protests in outrage over Mr. Trump and Mr. Musk’s decimation of public services and the mass firing of federal employees. The aim, in the words of an Indivisible founder, Leah Greenberg, was “piercing that sense of authoritarian inevitability.” I, for one, recall being able to breathe more freely knowing so many people were taking a fundamental lesson from the history of fascism to heart: Do not obey in advance.

 

Soon after, the No Kings protests brought even bigger crowds into the streets, culminating in what may have been the single largest day of protest — Oct. 18, 2025 — in American history. Research shows that the demonstrations reached deep into Trump country. It was an early sign that MAGA was vulnerable on red turf.

 

When Stephen Miller unleashed ICE and the Border Patrol, the grass-roots resistance evolved to meet the threat. From Chicago to Charlotte, concerned citizens, many of whom had never been activists before, received training in civil disobedience at churches. In Minnesota, ICE’s violent Operation Metro Surge was met with courage and defiance. After Renee Good and Alex Pretti were killed by federal immigration agents, the weekslong showdown between protesters and ICE became a moral referendum for the nation as the public witnessed what “mass deportation” actually entails.

 

Public opinion on immigration enforcement turned even more intensely against the administration, with one YouGov poll finding that half of respondents supported abolishing ICE. This month, Michigan and Maine elected progressive senators on platforms pledging to do just that. ICE had become an avatar of Republican authoritarianism, propelling Latino voters to swing toward Democrats at the polls.

 

It’s notable, for example, that in a Times/Siena poll of likely voters in Minnesota, “the state of democracy/corruption” was the most important issue after the economy in their decision about which congressional candidates to choose, perhaps because of their intimate experience of state violence. Nationally, the cost of living was the top issue for 34 percent of voters, but “preserving democracy” was a close second.

 

What exactly do people mean when they cite democracy as a key concern? It’s impossible to know for sure, but it’s hard not to imagine some respondents connecting that prompt to everything from disgust with the federal government’s blatant disregard for the rule of law to repudiating racist attacks on voting rights and D.E.I. It could also be rage against the president’s self-enrichment and embrace of the tech oligarchs and their anti-human vision of A.I.-control.

 

In 2026, being concerned about democracy meant something deeper than it did two years prior, when Democrats tried and failed to position themselves as defenders of a status quo imperiled solely by Mr. Trump’s recklessness. Some of this month’s winning candidates took a far different tack, echoing anti-oligarchy messaging long promoted by the democratic socialist left. Abdul El-Sayed’s slogan in Michigan, “Money out of politics, money in your pocket, Medicare for all,” states it plainly: Democracy as Americans know it is broken by the outsize power of the superrich, and this dynamic has steadily eroded “affordability” while preventing sensible and popular political reforms.

 

Many commentators have framed the Democratic Party’s pivot to anti-oligarchy messaging as a turn away from so-called culture wars and identity politics. But that’s too simplistic. Democrats have gotten better at framing the experience of marginalization, which often falls along racial and gender lines, in ways that underscore more broadly shared concerns, including the desire for dignity and security and a more responsive government.

 

In Tennessee, Victoria Broderick, the Democratic nominee in the Fourth Congressional District, was initially inspired to run because of her anger over the dismantling of abortion rights. She campaigned as a proud working-class mother of two, openly queer, pro-Palestine, Medicare-for-all supporting ally of trans youth who may yet flip her highly gerrymandered district (votes are still being counted). That she spent under $100,000 on the race only lends credibility to her call to get money out of politics.

 

That’s what real economic populism is: a democratic revolt against the capture and corruption of politics by moneyed interests, which is more than just a call for lower living costs. It is also fully compatible with a politics that refuses to pull punches about the far right’s authoritarian designs, and is inseparable from universal human rights.

 

Mr. Trump’s post-election elevation of Stephen Miller to chief of staff signals that the White House, however weakened, remains undeterred, even if the president has acknowledged that the ICE crackdowns may have been “too tough” and turned voters off. Mr. Miller, of course, is a promoter of white nationalist material who is an architect of the administration’s war on immigrants, an avowed enemy of international law, and a firm believer that might makes right. In short, the administration is doubling down on fascism.

 

This is not a moment for leftists, who make up a substantial number of Democratic voters, to shrink our ambitions or to soft-pedal the hideousness of the Republican agenda. The people occupying the White House, and their Big Tech enablers and political allies, have shown us that they would install themselves as our permanent overlords if they could. My co-author, Naomi Klein, and I call their politics “end times fascism,” an apocalyptic and kleptocratic movement that has little to offer its base except bigotry, destruction and data centers.

 

To deliver a decisive blow against Mr. Trump and his billionaire backers, we need to build on the antifascist organizing that has proved so effective thus far at beating them back. Mr. Trump and MAGA are flailing; if we let up now, the next iteration of the far right may be even more extreme.

 

Ultimately, affordability and antifascism are complementary: Insecurity often makes people more susceptible to far-right appeals, which means addressing affordability is part of a smart antifascist policy response, though not an adequate one on its own.

 

The midterms showed that a growing number of people, from all walks of life, want to be able to make ends meet. They also showed that ordinary people understand that the stakes are much more existential. This is a fight for a livable democratic future that we can’t afford to lose.


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


8) U.S. Loses Its Measles Elimination Status, a Historic Setback for American Health

The nation was once regarded as a global leader for reining in the highly contagious virus. Now, large outbreaks that sicken thousands could become routine.

By Teddy Rosenbluth, Nov. 17, 2026

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/17/well/us-measles-elimination-status.html

A sign on a glass door features a red stop sign. It gives instructions for patients seeking treatment for measles.

Rachel Wisniewski for The New York Times


Measles has come roaring back in the United States, as vaccination rates have fallen and cases of the once-extinguished virus have soared. That backslide has now cost the nation its measles elimination status, after the virus spread uninterrupted for more than a year.

 

“It’s a giant stain on our reputation,” said Jennifer Nuzzo, director of the Pandemic Center at the Brown University School of Public Health. “Everyone ought to be just utterly disgusted by the willing return back to an age of death and high cost.”

 

The announcement, made Tuesday by the Pan American Health Organization, ushers in a new era in which major outbreaks could routinely disrupt communities around the nation, sickening thousands of children. It also marks a highly embarrassing reversal for a country that showed the rest of the world it was possible to rein in the wildly contagious virus when it won elimination status in 2000.

 

State health officials have reported more than 7,700 cases of measles, including 10 deaths, since the resurgence first kicked off in a Mennonite community in Texas in January 2025. Hundreds have been hospitalized, many of them unvaccinated children. Infections have also risen among pregnant women and newborns, who are at increased risk of death and other dire health consequences.

 

“Losing measles elimination status has broader implications than losing a public health designation,” said Dr. Jarbas Barbosa, director of the Pan American Health Organization, in a news conference announcing the decision. “It means the virus has circulated for a prolonged period of time, putting families and communities at the risk of preventable illness, hospitalization and death.”

 

The organization also announced on Tuesday that Bolivia and Mexico had also lost its measles elimination status, posing another setback for North America’s handle on the highly contagious virus. Canada officially lost its measles elimination status last year.

 

“None of this had to happen,” said Dr. Peter Hotez, a vaccine scientist and pediatrician at the Baylor College of Medicine. “That’s what’s so tragic.”

 

The circumstances that have allowed measles to take root again in the United States have been brewing for years, public health experts said. Vaccination rates, which began falling during the Covid-19 pandemic, have continued to drop, and now sit well below the 95 percent needed to establish herd immunity.

 

In some communities, including many of the insular religious groups hit hardest by measles outbreaks, an even smaller share of children are vaccinated.

 

But experts said under the leadership of Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., federal health officials did too little to control outbreaks early on. And they criticized Mr. Kennedy himself for at times directly undermining efforts to improve vaccination rates, by promoting unproven treatments for measles and undermining confidence in childhood vaccines.

 

“I don’t think it’s an accident that this is happening under the current administration,” said Dr. William Moss, an epidemiologist at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health who has studied measles for more than 25 years.

 

Grace Davis Jamison, a spokeswoman for the Department of Health and Human Services, said in a statement that the department would continue working to “stop transmission, close vaccination gaps, strengthen outbreak response and protect Americans from measles.”

 

She said that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention convened a meeting this year to develop a national strategy to regain elimination status. (Losing measles elimination status does not carry any formal penalty.) Ms. Jamison pointed to the $100 million infusion the agency sent to states to help them respond to outbreaks of measles and other vaccine-preventable diseases.

 

But regaining elimination status is likely to be a monumental task, one that experts said may require a vast public education campaign, investment in on-the-ground immunization efforts and a push to strengthen school vaccination requirements, which several states have loosened in recent years.

 

Even if the C.D.C. and cash-strapped state public health departments make that kind of investment, it will probably be “many years before we get the situation back under control,” said Dr. David Kimberlin, a pediatric infectious disease expert at the University of Alabama at Birmingham.

 

While there were measles cases in the United States between 2000 and 2025, there were fewer than 200 cases most years, and many of them tied to international travel. When the virus did strike an unvaccinated community, the outbreaks did not continue for longer than a year, allowing the country to maintain its status.

 

That meant that many doctors around the country had never seen a case of measles before last year, when more children started arriving at hospitals gasping for breath or experiencing life-threatening brain swelling.

 

Many of those infected since 2025 have been young children, and several of the deaths have been in infants too young to be vaccinated.

 

“We are going to see a growing number of children, as well as young adults, dying from measles,” said Dr. Daniel Salas, who helps lead immunization efforts at the Pan American Health Organization.

 

That is not to mention the long-term health repercussions that are now “baked into our future,” said Dr. Cameron Wolfe, professor of infectious diseases at the Duke University School of Medicine. Even patients who appear to have recovered from measles may fall ill with an entirely different infection months or years later, because the virus weakens the immune system and leaves it more vulnerable to other threats.

 

In the next decade, experts also expect to see at least a few cases of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis, a devastating neurological condition that can occur after a measles infection and that slowly degrades the brain’s ability to access memory, control movement and, ultimately, breathe. It is nearly always fatal.

 

The resurgence of measles will have far broader consequences for American society. Already this year, hundreds of unvaccinated children have missed weeks of in-person classes this year while local health departments scrambled to stem the spread of the virus.

 

Since 2025, measles has cost the country roughly $125 million in medical care, lost productivity and public health resources, according to one estimate.

 

Public health experts are hopeful that the country will eventually reverse course, but some fear it will happen only after Americans see death and disability caused by measles in their own communities.

 

“Short of that, I’m not sure how to change the direction of this ship,” Dr. Kimberlin said. “That would take a lot of small coffins in the ground.”


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


9) Schools Are Closing Nationwide as Enrollment Drops. Parents Are Livid.

With fewer babies being born and more school choice, districts across the country have concluded they must downsize. Families are trying to push back.

By Sarah Mervosh and Jack Healy, Nov. 17, 2026

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/17/us/public-schools-closing-birth-rate-enrollment.html

Children stand shoulder-to-shoulder holding signs that read “Save Sunnyside Environmental” and “S.E.S.! Water!”

Students protested a school closure plan in Portland, Ore. Jordan Gale for The New York Times


The families show up angry and organized, wearing matching T-shirts and waving protest signs to vent their frustration at a crisis that has largely slipped under America’s political radar: Scores of neighborhood schools are closing.

 

Since last year, more than 100 public schools across the country have been slated for closure or consolidation, as districts grapple with dramatic enrollment declines that have led to strained budgets and half-empty buildings.

 

They are the first in a wave of school closures that is expected to accelerate in the years ahead as Americans have fewer and fewer children.

 

The issue got scant attention during the midterm elections compared with gas prices or the war in Iran. But it has become a personal, consuming fight for thousands of parents, liberal and conservative alike, who have thronged school-board meetings and formed grass-roots groups to argue that closures will scatter students and devastate neighborhoods anchored by local schools.

 

“It feels like our community is being dismantled,” said Hanna Neuschwander, who bikes her third grader and seventh grader to their neighborhood school in Portland, Ore., where 10 schools are being recommended for closure and others are being broken up and reconfigured.

 

Almost no type of district — urban or rural, affluent or poor — is immune. Pittsburgh is preparing to close 12 schools, and Tulsa, Okla. recently voted to close or consolidate 17. Five are closing around the Tampa Bay area in Florida, and three in Little Rock, Ark. In Colorado, schools are shuttering in the rich college town of Boulder and next to a mobile-home park outside Denver.

 

In New York City, the nation’s largest school district, enrollment has plunged from nearly 1 million to about 767,000 students over the last decade. Two small schools in Harlem are now on the potential closure list, and Mayor Zohran Mamdani is facing pressure to find solutions to a growing crisis.

 

Public-school enrollment is being battered on multiple fronts.

 

Americans worried about soaring prices and pessimistic about the future are having fewer children or forgoing parenthood altogether, and the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown has meant fewer immigrants are arriving and enrolling their children in public schools.

 

Public-school enrollment never fully recovered after plunging during the pandemic, and it is also facing pressure as more parents opt for charter schools, home-schooling or voucher-funded private schools.

 

“It was hard, but it was also necessary,” said Lori Goldstein, who as president of the Adams 12 school district in suburban Denver recently voted to close one middle school and five elementary schools. “People just aren’t having kids. Every year, our kindergarten class is getting smaller and smaller.”

 

In most cases, districts receive state and federal funding based on the number of students enrolled. Fewer students, districts say, means less money to pay for rigorous academic options, like advanced math, and a full slate of electives, like music, art and STEM, at every school — something districts hope to change by consolidating buildings.

 

Closures are a “last resort,” said Angela King Smith, a partner at Education Resource Strategies, a nonprofit that consults with school districts on finances. Districts typically start with smaller changes, like adjusting school boundaries or trying to woo new families — by expanding preschool or offering specialized programming, for example.

 

But “if those things are just not working,” she said, “it’s like, ‘Look, you’ve got to do something.’”

 

Often, schools in poorer neighborhoods struggle the most to fill classrooms and keep a full slate of options.

 

In Portland, enrollment has fallen from a peak of nearly 80,000 students in the 1960s to 42,000 today. The district says it has tried spreading music and art teachers out across schools, and it has increased high school class sizes to pay for counselors in some elementary schools. Still, about half of Portland’s students — and even fewer of its students in poverty — are in what the district considers a “sustainable school.”

 

“How are we going to achieve better for our kids if we maintain the status quo?” said Rashelle Chase-Miller, a Portland board member who believes closing some schools will help the district better serve its most vulnerable students.

 

For many families, the closures are a gut punch, injecting chaos and disruption to their children’s lives.

 

Parents are organizing on WhatsApp and Facebook, showing up to school-board meetings in their schools’ colors, and even going to court to try to block closures.

 

The plan in Portland has been particularly contentious. At a packed board meeting last month, parents and community members shoved past security, shouting “Shame on you!” and “Save our schools!” according to video posted by The Oregonian.

 

The superintendent, Kimberlee Armstrong, has faced accusations from teachers, parents and local Democratic Socialists of America organizers that she is part of a “right wing” effort to privatize education and hurt public schools.

 

Dr. Armstrong said in an interview that she was recommending closures as part of her commitment to all Portland students and the “long term stability” of the school system. “That is my job,” she said.

 

Some parents in Portland said they understood the need for changes but wanted the district to slow down and consider community input. “It’s not about ‘don’t close schools,’ but close schools the right way,” said Matt Coolidge, a parent who co-founded a grass-roots group, Save PDX Schools.

 

In Fort Collins, Colo., dozens of parents and students gathered outside the offices of the Poudre School District on a recent evening to urge the board to spare their schools.

 

For some of them, this was their first time joining a protest. But they wanted to come out for their schools and children.

 

“We’ve never been out to a protest before,” said Shelley Sutton, who brought her three young children to to the rally to save Timnath Elementary, home of the Cubs, one of five schools set to be closed.

 

The district said Timnath’s yellow-brick building — first built in 1919 — did not comply with the Americans With Disabilities Act and needed millions of dollars in upgrades.

 

But the Suttons said having Timnath in the neighborhood allowed them to walk their third-grader to school. If it closes, they said, many students will have to cross busy roads or an interstate to get to the closest school, making walking or biking dangerous.

 

“The school is the linchpin in the heart of town,” Ms. Sutton’s husband, Ian, said. “It’s the heart of the community.”

 

The district’s superintendent, Brian Kingsley, said more closures could loom if the student population continues to fall.

 

“This problem is not going to go away,” he said in an interview. “Nobody’s being asked to like these decisions, but it’s not the result of a local failure. Birthrates are lower. Fewer families are moving here.”

 

Some parents say that school boards are closing the wrong schools and putting unfair burdens on rural, immigrant or minority students.

 

In Minneapolis, a proposal to close up to 16 schools was criticized, in part, for including several schools in predominantly Black, working class neighborhoods.

 

“I hear parents say they feel angry. I hear parents say the trust in the district is lost,” said Shakiya Carter, a co-founder of Minneapolis Families for Public Schools, which opposed the plan and won a pause while the district considers its options.

 

Nationally, research shows that high-poverty schools and majority Black schools are more likely to be closed, even when accounting for similar enrollment declines.

 

Studies have found that closures can hurt students academically and may not save money, often because districts try to avoid laying off teachers and staff, the biggest line item on any district budget. The uncertainty can also spur families to look elsewhere — to private schools, charter schools or other districts — leading to new financial losses.

 

In Pittsburgh, a closure plan isn’t expected to be a huge cost saver, but the district hopes it will equalize resources.

 

At Arsenal Middle School, which serves mostly lower-income Black and Hispanic families in the gentrifying neighborhood of Lawrenceville, the student body has shrunk to 134 students, with just 37 eighth graders. That’s too few to offer 8th grade algebra, a pathway to higher level math that is available at some more affluent schools in the district.

 

With an influx of students from other middle schools, Arsenal hopes to offer algebra next year. David Saylor, a math teacher, said he has students who are ready to take it and that “parents absolutely love an advanced option.”

 

But as part of the plan, the elementary school on the other side of the building, Arsenal PreK-5, is closing. That will break up a tight-knit school community made up of many immigrant families.

 

The principal, Ruthie Rea, has been there 18 years, long enough to watch entire families of children come through the school. Next year, her students — her “Arsenal All Stars,” with their names on their lockers, and teachers who greet them with hugs — will be split among three different schools.

 

“I’m not letting my mind get there,” said Dr. Rea, who was awaiting word about where she and her staff will be reassigned. “We want this last year to be one that is super special.”


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


10) I.R.S. Opens Criminal Probes as Part of Trump’s Pursuit of Left-Wing Groups

An internal I.R.S. memo viewed by The New York Times reveals how the agency is carrying out President Trump’s orders to investigate “domestic terrorism.”

By Andrew Duehren, Reporting from Washington, Nov. 17, 2026

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/17/us/politics/irs-criminal-investigations.html

A person in a dark suit walks past the stone facade of an Internal Revenue Service building.

Under an order by President Trump after the killing of Charlie Kirk, the I.R.S. was told to investigate whether nonprofits were “directly or indirectly financing political violence or domestic terrorism.” Haiyun Jiang for The New York Times


The Internal Revenue Service has initiated at least four criminal investigations as part of the Trump administration’s crackdown on left-wing groups that began after the killing of Charlie Kirk last year, according to an internal agency memorandum viewed by The New York Times.

 

The subjects and current status of the four investigations are not specified in the pages of the memo viewed by The Times, which details work done by a group of a dozen I.R.S. officials detailed to a cross-agency task force formed in response to Mr. Kirk’s death on Sept. 10, 2025. President Trump ordered agencies across the government to investigate the antifascist movement, or antifa, and other groups that espouse “extremism on migration, race and gender,” among other views.

 

Under Mr. Trump’s order, the I.R.S. was told to investigate whether nonprofits were “directly or indirectly financing political violence or domestic terrorism.” In March, officials from the criminal investigations branch of the service began working with the task force out of the F.B.I. headquarters.

 

The I.R.S. work on the task force has also involved rapid response to events like protests at Delaney Hall, an immigrant detention center in Newark, N.J., the memo states. Protesters and Immigration and Customs Enforcement have repeatedly clashed at the site, and a Democratic member of Congress is among the people who have been charged with a crime after an encounter with federal agents there.

 

I.R.S. officials reviewed financial information, including subpoenaed Venmo records, about people arrested during the protests, as well as businesses that the officials believed could be funding them. At one point, I.R.S. officials used facial recognition and tattoo analysis databases to help identify individuals, the memo said.

 

Many nonprofits and their tax lawyers have feared that the I.R.S., with its vast stores of financial information and power to enforce tax law, could become a potent tool in the president’s vendetta against liberal organizations. That concern began last year, when Mr. Trump publicly called for the I.R.S. to strip elite universities and other nonprofits of their tax-exempt status, a move that would upend their finances.

 

But because audits and tax investigations are protected under federal taxpayer privacy law, it has been unclear to what extent the I.R.S. has heeded the Trump administration’s push to scrutinize left-leaning groups. The memo viewed by The Times is the first window into the work the I.R.S. has actually undertaken to carry out the demands from the White House.

 

The internal status report, circulated among leaders in I.R.S. Criminal Investigation, describes the activities of the I.R.S. team detailed to the task force between March and July of this year. The Times viewed the first six pages of the eight-page memo and did not view its two-page appendix identifying the targets of the I.R.S. investigations. One focus for the group is investigating people who doxx or threaten government officials, the memo states.

 

A spokesman for the I.R.S. said the agency’s criminal branch “has collaborated with federal law enforcement agencies, including the F.B.I., to investigate individuals and entities that may be funding domestic terrorism or political violence.”

 

In addition to the four criminal investigations mentioned in the memo, the group of I.R.S. special agents and analysts have also referred at least four tax-exempt groups to the civil side of the agency that conducts audits, the memo said. The document said that the group of I.R.S. officials had been assigned to nine grand juries and helped the F.B.I. with financial analysis, including of whether groups had improperly filled out Form 990, the main tax form for nonprofits.

 

The Trump administration has cast its focus on “domestic terrorism” as a way to prevent political violence, but its enforcement campaign has only fueled fears about the federal government’s penalizing lawful political activity. In the days after Mr. Kirk’s killing, the Justice Department pushed U.S. attorneys to investigate George Soros’s Open Society foundation, a major donor to liberal causes.

 

And in the spring, the government charged the Southern Poverty Law Center, a nonprofit group that has long tracked hate groups, with defrauding its donors. Prosectors have charged Tyler Robinson, a 23-year-old man, with killing Mr. Kirk and have not accused him of working with any outside group.

 

Within the I.R.S., officials have discussed the creation of a new process for revoking the tax-exempt status of nonprofit groups, according to three people familiar with the change. Organizations that have been indicted or have had senior members of their leadership indicted would face an expedited audit, conducted in a matter of months, that could result in the loss of their tax-exempt status, the people said. But I.R.S. lawyers have raised concerns about the legal rigor of such a process, and the agency has so far not implemented it.

 

Beyond the Delaney Hall protests, the I.R.S. detail to the F.B.I. task force has also helped work on the federal law enforcement response to the shooting at the White House Correspondents’ Association dinner in the spring, as well as a shooting at a mosque in San Diego in May. The I.R.S. group also assisted with the Ultimate Fighting Championship event that Mr. Trump hosted on the White House lawn in June, though its exact role is unclear.

 

But much of the memo viewed by The Times describes the bureaucratic challenges the I.R.S. officials have faced working with the F.B.I. The “continual turnover” of F.B.I. leadership on the task force and the bureau’s “culture of lack of information sharing” has made it difficult for the I.R.S. to establish itself in the task force, the memo stated. An F.B.I. spokesman did not respond to a request for comment.

 

The I.R.S. memo, which is unsigned, describes how, overall, opportunities for the group have been limited. Some potential financial crimes have been identified, the memo states, but they are not related to the task force’s work “because there was no specific threat directed at a government entity, its property or a government employee.” In some instances, other I.R.S. agents ignored emails from the task force or did not inform the group that they were already working a case, the memo said.

 

The I.R.S. group recommends that it be given a broader remit to focus more squarely on “investigating the misuse of 501(c)(3) organizations and/or individuals with nexus to terrorism,” referring to the tax code section that applies to many nonprofits. Under federal law, any organization that the federal government officially identifies as a terrorist group immediately loses its tax-exempt status.

 

With roughly 3,000 employees, the criminal investigation branch of the I.R.S. is a relatively small slice of the agency overall. But it has been frequently deployed as part of broader Trump administration initiatives. An inspector general report this year detailed the time I.R.S. criminal agents spent patrolling the streets of Washington and Memphis, Tenn., as part of the administration’s law enforcement efforts there. That came at the expense of work on criminal tax investigations, the inspector general found.


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*


*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*..........*